Information sharing builds resilience and attribution --- reduces vulnerabilities to attack
Housen-Couriel 22 --- Deborah Housen-Couriel, Chief Legal Officer and Vice-President Regulation for Konfidas Digital Ltd., a cyber and data protection consulting firm, She currently serves on the Advisory Board of the Hebrew University Law School’s Cyber Security Research Center and as a research fellow with the Reichman University’s Interdisciplinary Center Herzliya’s Institute for CounterTerrorism, Chapter 3 “Information Sharing as a Critical Best Practice for the Sustainability of Cyber Peace” in “Cyber Peace Charting a Path Toward a Sustainable, Stable, and Secure Cyberspace”, edited by Scott J Schakelford et al, published in 2022 by Cambridge Univ Press, Pages 39-41
The concept of cyber peace brings a much-needed, innovative perspective to discussions of the governance of cyberspace. The ambiguity, conflicting terminology, and lack of transparency with respect to activities by state and nonstate actors have characterized efforts to conceptualize and analyze this new area of human endeavor at least since John Perry Barlow’s 1996 Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace. Barlow’s (1996) proclamation that claimed cyberspace as a home for the “civilization of the Mind” and a “global social space” that must be kept free of governments, state sovereignty, and legal constructs – in effect, exempt from any type of governance – marked early on in the life of online activities the challenges and tensions that remain today for the global collective action problem of cyberspace governance. Thus, the distinctive perspective of cyber peace has the potential to set our analytical sights anew and to provide a framework for moving ahead with the normative projects connected to the aspects of cyberspace governance, including the ongoing elucidation of binding rules of international and domestic law that are applicable to cyberspace activities of state and nonstate actors.
Building on previous chapters that treat the concept of cyber peace in depth, the following definition focuses on four specific elements:
Cyber peace is […] not […] the absence of conflict […]. Rather it is the construction of a network of multilevel regimes that promote global, just and sustainable cybersecurity by clarifying the rules of the road for companies and countries alike to help reduce the threats of cyber conflict, crime and espionage to levels comparable to other business and national security risks. To achieve this goal, a new approach to cybersecurity is needed that seeks out best practices from the public and private sectors to build robust, secure systems and couches cybersecurity within the larger debate on internet governance (Shackelford, 2014, pp. xxv–xxvi).
The four elements emphasized in the above definition describe the fundamental connection between the goals of cyber peace and information sharing (IS), the subject of this chapter (Johnson et al., 2016, p. iii).1 Clarification of “rules of the road,” whether these are binding or voluntary; threat reduction, risk assessment, and best practices for carrying out these three tasks are precisely the substantive contribution that IS makes to the cybersecurity postures and strategies of stakeholders participating in any given IS platform. As detailed herein, such a platform optimally defines threshold norms of permissible and nonpermissible online behavior on the part of all actors, establishing the criteria for determining whether an individual, private organization, country, group of hackers, or even another autonomously acting computer has violated a rule (Deljoo et al., 2018, p. 1508). It also reduces vulnerability to cyber threats by lessening the informational asymmetries that characterize hostile cyber activities to the advantage of the attacker, and contributes to organizational risk assessment by integrating the information shared by other participants in the IS community into heightened “cyber situational awareness” for all sharers. Fourth, IS is readily framed and understood by a multiplicity of actors at the domestic level – private, governmental, and individual – as a best practice and, at the international level, as a confidence-building measure (CBM) for building trust among state and nonstate actors.2 These two characterizations of IS in the domestic and international jurisdictional arenas, respectively, are evidenced by the inclusion of IS modalities in many instances of national law and policy, as well as tens of multilateral and bilateral instruments for governing cyberspace at the international level (Housen-Couriel, 2017, pp. 46–84). Five examples of the latter are the 2015 Shanghai Cooperation Organization’s International Code of Conduct for Information Security, the UN GGE Report of July 2015, the OSCE’s Confidence-Building Measures for Cyberspace of 2016, the EU’s Network and Information Security Directive that entered into force in August 2016; and the 2018 Paris Call for Trust and Security in Cyberspace.
When IS implemented as a voluntary or recommended best practice or CBM in the context of these regulatory arrangements – rather than as a mandated regulatory requirement – it has the advantage of bypassing the legal challenges of achieving formal and substantive multistakeholder agreement on cyber norms. The difficulties of such normative barriers are often observed as characteristic of the contemporary cyber lay of the land. Either as a best practice (at the domestic level) or a CBM at the international level, IS has the advantage of bypassing the present challenges of achieving formal and substantive multistakeholder agreement on cyber norms that are inherent elements of national and multilateral legal regimes for the governance of cyberspace (Macak, 2016; Ruhl et al., 2020).
We propose in this chapter that, as IS platforms provide increasingly relevant, timely, and actionable data on vulnerabilities, including zero-day vulnerabilities (Ablon & Bogart, 2017); adversaries’ tactics, techniques, and procedures; malware tool configurations; and other tactical and strategic threat indicators, stakeholders will become more incentivized to increasingly trust IS platforms and to utilize them for both real-time response to hostile cyber activities and for building longterm cybersecurity strategies. Technological advances are easing this process, as platforms adopt new techniques for the automation of alerts and communications among sharers (Wagner et al., 2019). Thus, in instances when sharing communities are substantively and technologically optimized for cybersecurity, participants benefit from expertise and insights which may otherwise be unavailable to them with respect to developing threat vectors, mitigation of specific cyber risks, and real-time coordinated responses to hostile cyber events.