Only increased information sharing can build resilience capabilities and reduce harms of attack
Skopik et al 16 --- Florian Skopik Senior Scientist of the research program “IT Security”., Giuseppe Settanni joined AIT in 2013 as scientist and is currently working on national and European applied research projects regarding security in communication and information systems, Roman Fiedler is Scientist at the AIT Austrian Insititute of Technology and runs projects in the areas of telehealth and ICT security, “A problem shared is a problem halved: A survey on the dimensions of collective cyber defense through security information sharing”, Computers & Security Volume 60, July 2016, Pages 154-176, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0167404816300347
International collaboration is of the utmost importance for effective response mechanisms. Indeed, digital boundaries are not clearly defined and do not correspond to national frontiers. Moreover, recent publications show that threats such as malware (and botnets, in particular) are no longer an issue that people should deal with individually, but are increasingly a social and civic responsibility that affects all sectors of the digital society (Anonymous, 2012, ENISA, 2013b).
According to Helmbrecht et al. (2013), response mechanisms, containing numerous established policy initiatives, have been in place from the early days of ICT development. However, the deployment of ICT solutions used by citizens in their day-to-day lives is threatened by cyber attacks, targeting areas such as online payment, e-government services, and in general every critical infrastructure relying on computer networks. Finally, ICT is increasingly used in vandalism, terrorism, hacktivism, war and fraud that reduce the level of confidence citizens have in trustfully adopting such technology and exposes them to higher and higher danger.
Securing ICT systems within a confederation of countries needs to be coherent across geographical borders and consistently pursued over time.
The European Network and Information Security Agency (ENISA) is the main European body aiming at improving the convergence of efforts from the different Member States by encouraging the exchange of information, methods and results, and avoiding duplication of work. To this end, one of ENISA's tasks is to support European institutions and Member States by facilitating a coordinated approach to respond to network and information security threats.
The NIST supports the coordination of existing Computer Security Incident Response Teams (CSIRTs), when responding to computer security incidents, by identifying technical standards, methodologies, procedures, and processes related to Computer Security Incident Coordination (CSIC). NIST provides guidance on how multiple CSIRTs should cooperate while handling computer security incidents, and how CSIRTs should establish synergies with other organizations within a broader information sharing community.
4.2. The threat landscape
The cyber threat landscape evolves rapidly. Innovative methods to achieve malicious objectives are constantly taking shape in cyber space. Cyber-criminals and certain nation-states are aggressively pursuing valuable data assets, such as financial transaction information, product design blueprints, user credentials to sensitive systems, and other intellectual property. Attackers are armed with the latest zero-day vulnerabilities, high-quality toolkits, and social engineering techniques to perpetrate advanced targeted attacks. These threats use several stages and vectors to duck traditional defenses and find vulnerable systems and sensitive data (FireEye, 2013).
Attacks have changed in form, function, and sophistication from just a few years ago. The new generation of threats utilize both mass-market malware designed to infect multiple systems as well as sophisticated, zero-day malware to infect targeted systems. They leverage multiple attack vectors cutting across Web, email, and application-based attacks. Today's attacks are aimed at getting valuable data assets, sensitive financial information, intellectual property, authentication credentials, insider information, and each attack is often a multi-staged effort to infiltrate networks, spread, and ultimately exfiltrate the valuable data (FireEye, 2013).
Modern cyber attackers are not only motivated by economic reasons, but also their actions are more and more driven by impulses of social and political nature. International groups of associated activists and hacktivists, such as Anonymous, are nowadays well known for attacks on government, religious and corporate websites (Olson, 2012). In April 2007, Estonian government networks were harassed by a denial of service attack by unknown foreign intruders, following the country's spat with Russia over the removal of a war memorial. Some government online services were temporarily disrupted and online banking was halted. The attacks were more like cyber riots than crippling attacks and provoked outages lasting several hours or days (Herzog, 2011). In October 2010, Stuxnet, a complex piece of malware designed to interfere with Siemens Industrial Control Systems (ICS), was discovered in Iran, Indonesia, and elsewhere, leading to speculation that it was a government cyber weapon aimed at the Iranian nuclear program (Farwell and Rohozinski, 2011). On November 24, 2014, data belonging to Sony Pictures Entertainment including personal information about Sony Pictures employees and their families, e-mails between employees, information about executive salaries at the company, copies of unreleased Sony films, and other information were released by hackers who called themselves the “Guardians of Peace” or “GOP” (State of California Department of Justice Office of the Attorney General, 2014). They demanded the cancellation of the planned release of the film The Interview, a comedy about a plot to assassinate North Korean leader.
In order to develop effective defense strategies, it is necessary to understand the cyber threats and the methodologies put in place to deploy them. The components of the evolving cyber threat landscape are becoming increasingly complex. A comprehensive analysis of the reported cyber incidents needs to be performed to characterize the multitude of aspects a cyber threat involves. Priority lists of cyber threats, threat agents, attack methods and threat trends are all elements that need to be taken into consideration. This information is useful for cyber security experts assessing risks to various systems and developing cyber security policies for defending valuable information. Nevertheless, care should always be taken when analyzing such data – the fact that an event has happened frequently in the past does not guarantee that it will continue to happen.
Given that the cyber threat landscape develops very dynamically, the main challenge is to capture the trends as early as possible (cf. ENISA report, Helmbrecht et al., 2013).
In 2014, for Drive-by-exploits there is a shift from botnets to malicious URLs as the preferred means to distribute malware, because URLs are a more difficult target for law enforcement take-downs. Regarding Code Injection, a notable issue is attacks against popular content management systems (CMSs). Due to their wide use, popular CMSs make up a considerable attack surface that has drawn the attention of cyber criminals. An interesting aspect is the increased use of peer-to-peer (P2P) botnets – more difficult to locate and take down. Also, the use of botnet infrastructures to mine the “virtual currency” bitcoins is an emerging trend.
After the 2013 Spamhaus attack (Arstechnica, 2013), Domain Name System (DNS) reflection attacks have gained popularity within the Denial of Service attacks. Further, there is an increase in rogueware/scareware reported. One reason for the growth is the expansion of ransomware and fake antivirus distribution to mobile platforms such as Android. Cyber espionage attacks reached a dimension that went far beyond expectations (ENISA, 2013c). Several mass surveillance campaigns run by nation states have been recently uncovered (see Clarke, 2011 and Hudson, 2014), generating the indignation of the population. Identity theft led to some of the most successful attacks by abusing SMS-forwarders to commit significant financial fraud. These attacks were based on known financial Trojans (e.g. Zeus, SpyEye, Citadel) that have been implemented on mobile platforms and attack two-factor authentication. Search Engine Poisoning has also moved to mobile devices. These developments led to the conclusion that attackers remain one step ahead; quite often it suffices to exploit simple and well known weaknesses to cause havoc.
Although information sharing might seem in contrast with the attitude of some nation states performing espionage on other countries, this should not void information sharing efforts among organizations (especially those with similar infrastructures, and thus suffering from similar vulnerabilities or being potentially similarly attractive to attackers) from these countries on another layer. The key message of ENISA is to transfer knowledge from the cyber security community to the user groups for the purpose of strengthening cyber defense. To this end, effective information sharing, not only between security professionals, but also between all stakeholders dealing with critical ICT systems, needs to be enabled.