Cyber attacks on infrastructure collapses trade
Merk 18 [Olaf Merk, leads the ports and shipping work at the International Transport Forum (ITF) of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Lucie Kirstein and Filip Salamitov, "The Impact of Alliances in Container Shipping", 11/2/18, https://www.itf-oecd.org/sites/default/files/docs/impact-alliances-container-shipping.pdf]
In addition to alliances, vertical integration risks also reduce system resilience. Integration of shipping, terminal handling and hinterland transport could mean that whole transport chains are in the hand of just a few players, creating huge leverage for cyber-attacks, especially if parts of the chain are digitally connected. This became painfully evident during the NotPetya attack that hit Maersk ships and terminals (Box 7). Vertical integration could be considered to be related to the emergence of alliances. As service differentiation for the sea-leg is difficult in alliances – as the product is basically the same – one of the few remaining possibilities for individual carriers to differentiate is via vertical integration.
Box 7. Cyber security and risks associated to vertical integration
On 27 June 2017, a major cyber-attack began hitting firms mainly in France, Germany, Italy, Poland, Russia, Ukraine, the United Kingdom, and the United States. The attack is suspected to have started when hackers compromised the update server of Ukrainian tax accounting software company M.E.Doc so that it would distribute a malware referred to as “NotPetya” throughout its network. The malware further propagated itself notably via an exploit using a vulnerable Microsoft Windows network protocol. After analysis of the encryption routine of the malware, experts from Kaspersky came to the conclusion that the attack, although appearing as a ransomware attack, did not allow victims to recover their data even after paying the ransom, and the aim was therefore suspected to be directed at major disruption instead of financial gain for hackers (Ivanov and Mamedov, 2017). The carrier Maersk was presumably contaminated by this malware via software used by one of its offices in Ukraine. Maersk was forced to shut down many of its operating systems to stop the attack from spreading. The company was unable to process new orders and cranes were operated manually at some of its 76 container ports. The disruption caused major delays and led to rerouting of several vessels to ports not, or less, affected (Odell et al./FT, 2017). At least 17 terminals operated by APMT got infected by Maersk’s central IT infrastructure (Reuters, 2017). A number of terminals were unable to identify which shipment belonged to whom and therefore needed to clear cargo manually. The largest Indian port JNPT operated by Maersk’s APMT was forced to shut down and the terminal Maasvlakte II in Rotterdam stopped operations completely for a full week, which led to a highly congested service level.
According to Maersk’s annual report for 2017, the attack mainly impacted Maersk Line, APM Terminals and Damco. The effect on profitability was estimated to be around USD 250-300 million, with the vast majority of the impact related to Maersk Line in the third quarter (Maersk, 2018). Maersk estimated a 20% drop in volume and lost out on carrying 70 000 40-foot containers within the two weeks of the attack. Besides lost revenue, the attack also involved high costs of rebuilding its IT infrastructure. At the moment of the cyber-attack, Maersk did not own any cyber risk insurance. The company reported that 4 000 new servers, 45 000 new PCs, and 2 500 applications had to be reinstalled (Chirgwin/The Register, 2018). Actual impacts on Maersk’s performance could be higher than reported and probably stretch beyond the second half of 2017 (Porter/Lloyd’s List, 2017a). In April 2018, analysts speculated that the attack could have cost Maersk group over USD 500 million in expenses and lost profit. Others situate the cost between USD 400-500 million because the effect from the attack continued in the fourth quarter of 2017 and led Maersk to make investments in new infrastructure and insurances. Furthermore, the cyber-attack could have had an extended impact on market shares until the first quarter of 2018 (Beck/ShippingWatch, 2018). Although for most affected terminals it took a few days before they could resume operations completely, shippers were affected by delays of up to two months, because Maersk reportedly had difficulties in allocating new slots and tracking and assigning correct data to containers. The impact was widely felt by interviewed shippers and Lloyd’s List reported a similar observation that nearly two months after the attack, Maersk was still dealing with containers in transit at the time of the attack (Porter/Lloyd’s List, 2017b). One of the interviewed shippers reports having received additional demurrage invoices due to complications and delays caused by the cyber-attack, which suggests the carrier might have tried to shift part of the costs of the attack to their consumers.
Maersk’s global coverage, as well as strong horizontal and vertical integration in the sector further facilitated the knock-on effect of the cyber-attack. Companies who are reliant upon common IT infrastructure will logically suffer business interruption simultaneously when that infrastructure is compromised. Since supply chains are highly interconnected and even more so with increasing automation and digitalisation, this can result in an insecure operating environment even for those firms that make cyber security a priority. However, there is not only interdependence in IT infrastructure, but also in the utilisation of common assets. According to SeaIntel analysis, 20 other carriers transported containers on-board Maersk vessels around the time of the cyber-attack (SeaIntel, 2017; 319). MSC was the most affected with 23 vessel sharing agreements and four slot-charters, followed by Safmarine and Hamburg Süd. The most affected outside the 2M alliance and Maersk ownership was CMA CGM, with six vessel sharing agreements and four slot charter agreements with Maersk. The shipping sector is the backbone of international trade and ports are a vital part of every country’s infrastructure. Any major disruptions in supply chains can therefore have impacts on the overall economy. The scale of the cyber-attack and the many interconnections that exist vertically and horizontally in this industry could transform the collateral and rather accidental damage on a firm that was presumably not directly targeted, into a systemic risk for global trade.