Hybrid warfare disrupts NATO’s ontological security---reproduces the narrative of the “other” and turns the K---strengthening collective identity solves
Bahar Rumelili 15, Professor and Jean Monnet Chair at the Department of International Relations, Koc University, Istanbul, “Identity and desecuritisation: the pitfalls of conflating ontological and physical security,” Journal of International Relations and Development volume 18, pages52–74 (2015), https://link.springer.com/article/10.1057/jird.2013.22
With regard to ontological security, the distinction between security and insecurity is the more critical one. In a state of ontological insecurity, the Self experiences instability and uncertainty of being. Ontological insecurity refers to a state of disruption where the Self has lost its anchor for the definition of its identity and, consequently, its ability to sustain a narrative and answer questions about doing, acting, and being (Kinnvall 2004). It may arise from deep uncertainty (Mitzen 2006a) and/or from the failure to have its sense of Self affirmed by others (Zarakol 2010). Conversely, in a state of ontological security, the Self experiences a stable, certain, and consistent social existence, where it remains in control about its identity and capacity for action. While I do not rule out the possibility of a state of ontological asecurity, where the Self is simply not concerned with the stability and certainty of its identity, I do not explore this possibility and how it varies across different states of physical security in this article.
Having identified different states of physical and ontological security, I make the further assumption that since ontological and physical security are distinct, states of security do not vary uniformly across the ontological and physical layers of security. One can be at a state of physical insecurity while being at a state of ontological security, and vice versa. Consequently, Table 1 charts out the four possible states of security based on the conception of security as both ontological and physical.
The state of ontological insecurity/physical (in)security is one where the Self experiences concern about physical harm and the instability and uncertainty of its being. Ontological insecurity tempts actors to engage in practices that mark Others as not only different, but also as morally inferior and threatening (Campbell 1992). Ontological insecurity and physical (in)security reproduce one another. As actors seek ontological security through constructing Others as threats to their security-as-survival, they mobilise their physical defences in the pursuit of physical security through representing the sources of threat as different and morally inferior.
Similarly, in a state of ontological security/physical (in)security, actors experience stability and certainty of being in a relationship where the Other is constructed as threat to their security-as-survival. Consequently, they remain locked into conflict-producing routines to maintain their certainty of being (Mitzen 2006a). In protracted conflicts such as in Cyprus and Israel/Palestine, this state of security sustains a stable Self/Other relationship based on enemy roles. When in such a state of security, minority and majority groups, migrants and host societies perceive and represent each other’s identities as radically different and inherently incompatible, and reproduce these perceptions and representations through acts of securitisation in order to ensure their ontological security. The states of ontological insecurity/physical (in)security and ontological security/physical (in)security are both securitised states; however, whereas the former compels actors to construct new narratives of difference and threat and engage in the securitisation of new issues to regain their certainty and stability of being, the latter compels actors to reproduce the existing narratives and continue the securitisation of existing differences and conflicts to maintain it.
The state of ontological security/physical asecurity is certainly the most attractive state of security from a normative point of view. Security communities in international relations, and in particular, the European non-war community (Wæver 1998) and the Nordic community (Browning and Joenniemi 2012) constitute the best examples of such a state of security in international relations. A collective identity discourse makes it possible for states in security communities to maintain the us/them distinctions, which are necessary for the certainty and stability of being, while remaining in a state of physical asecurity vis-à-vis one another (Mitzen 2006b; Browning and Joenniemi 2012). In this state of security, conflicts are sustainably resolved; issues that have propelled conflict in the past are either settled or have shed their physical security-ness, and are negotiated in normal political channels. Yet, identity differences maintain their ontological security-ness as groups reproduce their distinct identities through various social and cultural practices.