Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

CBM (but is that IS with hostile actors?)

Housen-Couriel 22 --- Deborah Housen-Couriel, Chief Legal Officer and Vice-President Regulation for Konfidas Digital Ltd., a cyber and data protection consulting firm, She currently serves on the Advisory Board of the Hebrew University Law School’s Cyber Security Research Center and as a research fellow with the Reichman University’s Interdisciplinary Center Herzliya’s Institute for CounterTerrorism, Chapter 3 “Information Sharing as a Critical Best Practice for the Sustainability of Cyber Peace” in “Cyber Peace Charting a Path Toward a Sustainable, Stable, and Secure Cyberspace”, edited by Scott J Schakelford et al, published in 2022 by Cambridge Univ Press, Pages 54-

Building on this understanding of IS as a best practice, it is argued here that IS further supports sustainable cyber peace as a CBM at the international level, among the states, international organizations, and multinational companies that are critical to ensuring global cybersecurity. The framing of IS as a CBM, rather than as a binding, substantive norm to which these entities are subject as a matter of law or policy, is beneficial to the utilization of IS platforms at the international level (Borghard & Lonergan, 2018). By sidestepping substantive multilateral commitments, IS can be more readily utilized to support cybersecurity and cyber peace. Examples where this has occurred include the UN’s 2015 GGE (United Nations General Assembly, 2015), the OSCE’s 2016 listing of cybersecurity CBMs (Organization for Security and Co-Operation in Europe, 2016), and the 2018 Paris Call for Trust and Security in Cyberspace (Principle 9).

CBMs were originally used in the context of the Cold War to further disarmament processes in the context of the diplomatic and political standoff between the USSR and the West. Nonmilitary CBMs have been defined more generally as “actions or processes undertaken … with the aim of increasing transparency and the level of trust” between parties (Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, 2013). They are “one of the key measures in the international community’s toolbox aiming at preventing or reducing the risk of a conflict by eliminating the causes of mistrust, misunderstanding and miscalculation” (Pawlak, 2016, p. 133). CBMs are also critical in the global cybersecurity context and have been described as a “key tool in the cyber peacebuilder’s toolkit” (Nicholas, 2017).

In a 2017 in-depth study of eighty-four multilateral and bilateral initiatives addressing the collective action challenges of cybersecurity, including treaties, codes of conduct, agreements, memoranda and public declarations, IS was found to be included as an agreed cybersecurity measure in more than 25 percent of such initiatives (twenty-one out of the total eighty-four) (Housen-Couriel, 2017, pp. 51–52). Moreover, the analysis was able to isolate several specific elements of IS, discussed above, that were individually included in this top quarter: IS measures in general15; establishment of a specific national or organizational point of contact for information exchange; and sharing of threat indicators (Housen-Couriel, 2017, pp. 51–52).16 These elements were three out of a list of a dozen CBMs that occur with sufficient frequency to be included in a “convergence of concept” with which diverse stakeholders – states, regional organizations, intergovernmental organizations, specialized UN agencies, standards organizations, private corporations, sectoral organizations, and NGOs – have incorporated into cybersecurity initiatives.17 The study concluded that, while such cyberspace stakeholders are frequently willing to incorporate general arrangements for IS (it is in fact the leading agreed-upon cyber CBM in the initiatives that were studied), and even to specify a national or organizational point of contact, they are less willing to commit to a 24/7, real-time exchange of cybersecurity related information (Housen-Couriel, 2017, p. 67). This finding indicates a gap that should be considered in the context of further leveraging IS in the context of cyber peace.

Nonetheless, as noted above, IS as a CBM holds the advantage of bypassing the present, considerable challenges of achieving formal and substantive multistakeholder agreement on substantive cyber norms, until such time as such binding norms are legally and geopolitically practicable (Efroni & Shany, 2018; Finnemore & Hollis, 2016; Macak, 2017). A few examples of binding domestic law and international regulatory requirements for organizational participation in IS platforms do exist, such as the pan-EU regime established under the EU NIS (Directive 2016/1148), the Estonian Cybersecurity Act of 2016, and the US Department of Defense disclosure obligations for contractors when their networks have been breached. However, there are many more based on voluntary participation, such as the CISCP and FS-ISAC reviewed above, Israel’s FC3, and the global CERT and CSIRT networks of 24/7 platforms for cyber threat monitoring, including the EU network of more than 414 such platforms (European Union Network and Information Security Agency, 2018).

For the purposes of its analysis in this chapter, IS constitutes as a nonbinding CBM that also constitutes a best practice for bolstering cybersecurity and cyber peace, yet does not require a binding legal basis for its implementation. The critical issue of the use of regulatory measures, both binding and voluntary, to promote IS for optimal cybersecurity and cyber peace is, as noted above, an issue for further research.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.