Their evidence is hyperbole.
Valeriano & Maness 18 Brandon Valeriano, PhD, Chair of Armed Politics at the Marine Corps University, Cyber Security Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council, & Ryan Maness, an American cybersecurity expert, Defense Analysis Professor at Naval Postgraduate School. [How We Stopped Worrying about Cyber Doom and Started Collecting Data, Politics and Governance, 6(2), Cogitatio Press]
Moderate and measured takes on cyber security threats are swamped by the recent flood of research and policy positions in the cyber research field offering hyperbolic perspectives based on limited observations. This skewed perspective suggests constant cyber disasters that are confronting humanity constantly. The general tone of the debate argues that cyber war is already upon us and our future will only witness more cyber doom. However, these hyperbolic perspectives are being countered by empirical investigations that produce the opposite of what is to be expected. It is generally observed that limited cyber engagements throughout the geopolitical system are the dominant form of interaction. Our task here is to offer a different path forward. We first posit what can be known about cyber security interactions with data as well as what cannot. Where is the water's edge in cyber security research? We then examine the known works in the field that utilize data and evidence to examine cyber security processes. Finally, we conclude with an offering of what types of studies need to be done in the future to move the field forward, away from the prognostication and generalizations so typical in the discourse in this constantly changing and growing field. Keywords cyber conflict; cyber security; cyber strategy; data collection; quantitative methods Full Text: 1. The Challenge of Cyber Security Threat Data Beginning in 2014, various news organizations began reporting on a particular cyber security firm, Norse Corporation, and their active cyber threat map (Walker, 2015). Mashable noted in 2016 that "the global cyber war is raging on, and this mesmerizing map shows just how serious it has become" (Gallucci, 2016). The map is dynamic, colorful, and gets the point across quickly, a criterion for any decent visualization of data. As late of August 2017, the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) tweeted out a link and photo of the threat maps suggesting it represented ongoing cyber-attacks (DIA, 2017). Yet this map is not a very clear representation of any real threats that nationstates face on a daily basis. Unfortunately, the Norse cyber threat map does not represent active threat data, but attacks, likely by bots, on preset honeypots. Honeypots are a method of providing data on fake targets to either distract the opposition from the real targets or to deter an aggressor from attacking in the first place (Gartzke & Lindsay, 2015). While sometimes a useful method to gather threat intelligence if presented a sleight of hand for an attractive target, honeypots as reported in popular discourse are not exactly an accurate representation of the cyber threat landscape. In this case, the goal was to demonstrate the ability to track global attacks to gain interest in the company and promote its capabilities. Nearly all active threat maps either present data tracking honeypots and various bot networks that are devoid of human agency, simply presenting what is in fact fake data. Active representation of the threat landscape is the goal, but the reality is that the picture of the cyber security threat landscape we currently have is incomplete, misleading, or outright fake. High profile data breaches have been consuming media narratives for at least a decade. With each act of cyber disruption or espionage, pundits as well as government officials and several academics declare that cyberwar-fare is upon us, is the future of warfare, and it is only a matter of time before a "Cyber Pearl Harbor" wreaks havoc on the American homeland (Gurdus, 2016). With this new revolution in military affairs, the battlefield, according to some, is forever changed and the next big war could very well be a cyberwar (Clarke & Knake, 2010; Kello, 2013). Politicians, pundits, and practitioners have jumped on this doomsday narrative and have promoted cyber arms races, offensive advantage, and deterrence strategies to stay one step ahead of would be adversaries in order to prevent them from infiltrating networks out of fear of massive retaliation. These revolutionists point to acts such as Stuxnet, Shamoon, Sony, and the Office of Personal Management (OPM) hack as the new norm of conflict between states, and that the US is losing ground with every tolerated cyber-attack on American networks.