Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No impact---technically impossible and the explosion is contained.

Chalk 10—Adjunct Political Scientists at RAND, Adjunct Professor at the Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, and a PhD in political science from the University of British Columbia [Peter, “Assessing the Recent Terrorist Threat to the Malacca Strait,” CTC Sentinel, Vol. 3, Iss. 4, April, p. 9-11, Emory Libraries]

While there is little doubt concerning the economic salience of the Malacca Strait, carrying out decisive attacks against ships transiting through this corridor is somewhat more challenging than commonly portrayed. One of the most frequently postulated scenarios is that terrorists could attempt to disrupt the commercial viability of the Strait, either by detonating a hijacked oil or LNG tanker to shut down a prominent commercial terminal (such as the Port of Singapore) or by scuttling a large ship to block the through-passage of maritime traffic.8 Although theoretically possible, realization of both attack contingencies would be difficult to achieve.

Igniting pressurized LNG or oil is technically problematic. Unless these substances vent in their liquid form and mix with air in the correct ratio, the probability of either substance fully catching fire is extremely low. Even if this did occur, the lateral force of any subsequent explosion would likely be contained by the tanker’s hull, which would force the destructive energy upwards rather than outwards (thus minimizing its destructive potential).9 Sinking a major oceangoing freighter is equally as challenging and would, at a minimum, require the perpetrating group to have ready access to a large quantity of explosives, the time and means to transport this material and the expertise to know where to place the bombs to cause a critical breach. These logistical and knowledge barriers would pose formidable barriers for a single attack—much less an assault that targeted two or three ships (which would be required to truly block the Strait).10

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.