Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Attacks will be limited --- can’t escalate

Valeriano & Maness 18 – Brandon Valeriano, PhD, Chair of Armed Politics at the Marine Corps University, Cyber Security Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council. Ryan Maness, an American cybersecurity expert, Defense Analysis Professor at Naval Postgraduate School. [How We Stopped Worrying about Cyber Doom and Started Collecting Data, Politics and Governance, 6(2), Cogitatio Press]

6. Expanding Cyber Security Data Our team has been coding cyber incident data since 2010 and serves as a unique example of how the process of collecting cyber security data and evidence can be done. Our first peer reviewed published work appeared in 2014 in Journal of Peace Research (Valeriano & Maness, 2014). In this article we note that cyber conflict is much more restrained than generally understood by popular discourse. Threat inflation is ripe in cyber security, and the real use of cyber tools seems to be to enhance the power of strong states.

The data that Valeriano and Maness (2014, 2015) have built challenges the cyber revolution perspective and does so with the tools of social science, and is a necessary turn given the general tone of the debate. We first determine that a viable data collection method in light of limited resources was to focus on states that are committed interstate rivals (Diehl & Goertz, 2001). This allows us to focus on those actors with an intense history of recent hostilities that should be the most likely users of cyber technology on the battlefield (Maness & Valeriano, 2018).

In our research (Maness & Valeriano, 2016; Maness, Valeriano, & Jensen, 2017; Valeriano & Maness, 2014, 2015), we have been able to marshal a massive amount of evidence that is useful in dissecting the actual trends on the cyber battlefield in a geopolitical context. We demonstrate that while cyber-attacks are increasing in frequency, they are limited in severity, are directly connected to traditional territorial disagreements, and mostly take the shape of espionage and low-level disruptive campaigns rather than outright warfare.

Given this data-based perspective, we question the dynamics of the cyber security debate and offer a countering theory where states are restrained from using more malicious cyber actions due to the limited nature of the weapons, the possibly of blowback, the connection between the digital world and civilian infrastructure, and the reality that any cyber weapon launched can be replicated and used right back against the attacker. Given all of these perspectives gleamed from the data, we must moderate our views about the transformation that is offered by cyber strategists who stress a more revolutionist tone (Lango, 2016).

Social science clearly matters for contemporary technological policy debates. Absent rigorous methods, much of what is in the field is basically guesswork. Our work really owes an intellectual debt to J. David Singer, who started the effort to quantify war at the University of Michigan with the Correlates of War (COW) project (Small & Singer, 1982). Our project builds on this methodology and uses many of the same coding strategies. We recognize that data is a work in progress and seek to build more and more knowledge through subsequent updates. By gathering the full picture, we can gain the perspective that really matters in these emerging policy debates regarding the cyber battlefield.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.