Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Advanced techniques make attribution impossible

Finlay & Payne 19 --- Lorraine Finlay is a lecturer in the School of Law at Murdoch University, Christian Payne is a Lecturer in Computer Science at Murdoch University, “The Attribution Problem and Cyber Armed Attacks”, American Journal of International Law>AJIL Unbound>Volume 113, 24 June 2019, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-journal-of-international-law/article/attribution-problem-and-cyber-armed-attacks/ADC0F451A9B560D8A070A753E61E874F

There are, broadly speaking, two aspects to the attribution problem. The first is the technical problem of how to identify the true origin of a particular attack and the identity of those who carried it out. The second is the legal question of whether and if so, when, factual attribution allows a state to be held responsible for the cyberattack under international law.

The technical consequences of the unique characteristics of cyberattacks have been widely acknowledged. Dan Efrony and Yuval Shany have highlighted two key differences between cyber and other kinds of attacks: the boundlessness and anonymity of the cyber domain.Footnote11 As cyberspace is not limited by physical or geographical borders, questions of jurisdiction and enforcement become more complex. Perpetrators use various techniques to obscure their true location, and isolating the origin of a cyberattack is extraordinarily difficult when attacks are routed through multiple machines in multiple locations across the world. These techniques make the task of retrospectively establishing a forensic link between an attacker and an incident extremely difficult. They allow cyberattacks to be carried out with little risk to those involved, with perpetrators able to mask their identity and potentially even misattribute blame.

Thus, cyberattacks often take more time to detect and evaluate than traditional kinetic attacks. This analysis might require using classified intelligence and technological capabilities that a state would prefer not to reveal. All of these factors make it challenging to attribute cyberattacks.

These technical difficulties have two main consequences for attribution, both of which are critical in relation to cyber armed attacks. The first is that the risk of misattribution is heightened, leading to the potential for serious conflict escalation if a state mistakenly targets an innocent third party in its self-defense response. The second is that the length of time it will realistically take to correctly identify the perpetrator will very likely mean that it will be significantly harder for a state to satisfy the factors of immediacy and necessity required to lawfully exercise its right of self-defense.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.