NATO wont share
Herpig & Reinhold 18 --- Sven Herpig, PhD, project director for international cyber security policy, and Thomas Reinhold, research associate and PhD student at the Department of Science and Technology for Peace and Security (PEASEC) at TU Darmstadt“Spotting the bear: credible attribution and Russian operations in cyberspace”, European Union Institute for Security Studies (EUISS) (2018), https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/resrep21140.7.pdf
Although crucial to solving the challenge, the intelligence component has been the most underrated aspect in the public debate. The reason for that is the classification of intelligence materials and thus their rare exposure to public scrutiny. After the US presidential elections in 2016, the American intelligence community issued a declassified intelligence report18 that was supposed to convince the public of Russia’s guilt. It however achieved almost the opposite effect because – due to declassification – the public report no longer contained any hard proof of Russian intervention. When asked whether they think Russia attempted to meddle in the 2016 presidential elections, 45% of respondents in the US answered either that they do not know or that it is not true.19 At the end of the day, it is the state’s strategic choice how much it discloses about what it knows and how it obtained its intelligence. Therefore, credible attribution is indeed within the realms of possibility. Whether that proof can be presented to international organisations (e.g. UN, NATO) and/or the public or not is a different story as this would likely mean exposure of the intelligence operation. Revealing such an intelligence operation would decrease the likelihood of it still being effective in the future. If attackers follow the counter-response to their actions closely, they might be able to identify what measures were used to track them down and circumvent/avoid them if possible.