Loss of offensive capabilities, particularly zero-days, causes China to invade Taiwan
Ramos 21 --- Capt Allison R. Ramos Squadron Officer School Class 21-D, Flight B-19, “Cyber Deterrence: Controlling Escalation in Taiwan”, Website created Sept 17th 2021, https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/ISR/student-papers/AY21-22/CyberDeterrence_ControllingEscalation_Ramos.pdf
The Deterrence Operations Joint Operation Guide (DOJOC) defines deterrence as the ability to “Convince adversaries to not take action that threaten US vital interests by means of decisive influence over their decision making … [to] change the decision calculus of an adversary by denying benefits, imposing costs, or encouraging adversary restraint.”13 One method to deter is the cyber domain is through a forward-deployed presence. The US Cyber Command (USCYBERCOM) has included the concept as a central focus through superiority through persistence.14 The goal is to deploy as close to the adversary activity as possible, allowing the research of weaknesses, intentions, capabilities, and ability to counter-attack.15 USINDPACOM reinforces a cyber alliance with the ROK, Japan, and Australia to include information sharing and cyber attack response commitments.16 It lists the Philippines as a nation that the US will support specifically in an armed attack in the South China Sea.17 However, it does not mention Taiwan or cyber attacks. Forward deploying in cyberspace assumes that the US can act in cyberspace while controlling escalation and the persistence will deter others from cyber attacks.
Forward deployed troops allow for the normalization of cyber operations, which decreases the risk of escalatory response in a conflict situation. The decision to forward deploy in cyberspace includes cyber protection teams, operations within allied networks, operations against adversary networks, intelligence sharing with allies and partners, and using malware to set up critical national infrastructure to be effected.
The US must forward deploy troops because of the organizational decision to support Taiwan. The 2017 National Security Strategy included Taiwan and stated the US would provide for Taiwan’s legitimate defense needs and help deter coercion.18 The Interim National Security Strategy Guidance reaffirmed that guarantee, including comments that Taiwan is a democracy and critical economic and security partner in line with American commitments.19 The US values democracy, human rights, and human dignity as the basis for all top-level doctrine and strategies. Each document includes spreading and securing democracy as part of its core mission. In a cyber event with China, China could stifle the fundamental right to freedom of information or speech through a DDoS attack as was seen in Hong Kong or a zero-day attack that could have strategic-level effects on critical national infrastructure. The US must deter Chinese aggression towards Taiwan as aligned with their diplomatic pledge.