Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Our framework solves their offense, but their framework links to ours.

Andrews 13 — Nathan Andrews, Trudeau and Vanier Scholar in the Department of Political Science at the University of Alberta (Canada), former Banting Postdoctoral Fellow at Queen's University (Canada), holds a Ph.D in Political Science from the University of Alberta (Canada), 2013 (“Beyond the Ivory Tower: A Case for ‘Praxeological Deconstructionism’ as a ‘Third Way’ in IR Theorising,” Third World Quarterly, Volume 34, Number 1, Available Online to Subscribing Institutions via Taylor & Francis Online, p. 67-69)

The second premise derives from some critical scholars’ refusal to offer specific alternatives. Richard Ashley (as well as many post-structural, postcolonial, and post-development scholars), for instance, will argue that it is not the goal of critical theory to provide alternatives, as such an endeavour defeats the self-reflexivity that undergirds the theory. But this is problematic because, while these theories reveal the agency in the theory, there is no clarity of purpose in terms of ‘actionable’ leeway for the agent. Also, instead of glorifying realism, for instance as offering a ‘timeless wisdom’,66 the followers in this camp should be more reflexive so as to overcome the inert determinism and parochialism that underpin their theorising. Closely related to the second justification is the argument that the purpose of both theoretical and empirical analyses is not only to understand the world but also to change it. This change is not possible if critical theorists engage solely in inward-looking critiques of existing theories without providing a programmatic understanding of what their perspectives entail or how the existing condition can improve. [end page 67] Additionally, as the need for theoretical pluralism becomes more apparent, PD assists in making sure the notion of ‘pluralism’ moves from being a buzzword to an actual practice. Essentially most IR theories have four main themes in common: power, order, structure and agency—although the emphasis placed on each of these elements differs from theory to theory. Praxeologically oriented deconstruction helps to elucidate these four components without taking any aspect of them for granted. The argument here recognises the ontological and epistemological difficulties one falls into when thinking of a ‘third way’—the difficulty of having so many established scholars and theorists disagree with the approach on many grounds, even including grounds of originality and usefulness. But the point is that, while we emphasise, for instance, what Ashley calls the ‘four p’s’—process, practice, power and politics67—we need to explore the structure and utility of the state in contemporary world politics—and by so doing unveil the axes of domination in existing structures. This is therefore an approach which symbolises the mutually constitutive synergies between knowledge/theory and praxis/practice, as explained below, rather than one that seeks to revolutionise the entire field of study by turning it upside down.

This approach does not simply seek to reimagine ‘deconstruction’ but rather attempts to show that deconstruction, without praxis, ends at a point which leaves the individual subject unable to ascertain what options of social transformation are available.68 The main contention in recent times has been between those who call themselves ‘rationalists’ and the ‘constructivists’, although neither possesses a concise set of theoretical and methodological assumptions that explain the entirety of IR. As the socio-political phenomena IR addresses are often subjective and context-specific, there is no ‘scientific truth’ to be had which will transcend space and time. The ontology of PD, as evident from Figure 1, is that there is no one world or ‘truth’ out there, if any, and in the same manner there is no single way of knowing or standard by which ‘good’ knowledge is measured. In this case ‘truth is always contingent, always a matter for debate and always partial’, meaning that ‘truth is not “out there”, waiting to be discovered’.69 Rather, there are multiple understandings which reside in [end page 68] different sites—times and spaces. A ‘third way’ is thus crucial, especially for people who are concerned with both discursive interpretations and real (emancipatory) alternatives.70 It is only in this way that the discipline can become transformative or pro-change while taking into cognisance the fact that change can occur from both within and outside established arenas of power. PD also shows that there is no point in ‘throwing the baby out with the bathwater’; although the water is dirty, the baby can be saved lest the purpose of bathing the baby itself becomes self-defeating. This speaks to the freedom and flexibility this approach gives to the researcher in choosing from multiple perspectives.71

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.