Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The most important question is: How can we actually make the world a better place? Only our framework asks it.

Andrews 13 — Nathan Andrews, Trudeau and Vanier Scholar in the Department of Political Science at the University of Alberta (Canada), former Banting Postdoctoral Fellow at Queen's University (Canada), holds a Ph.D in Political Science from the University of Alberta (Canada), 2013 (“Beyond the Ivory Tower: A Case for ‘Praxeological Deconstructionism’ as a ‘Third Way’ in IR Theorising,” Third World Quarterly, Volume 34, Number 1, Available Online to Subscribing Institutions via Taylor & Francis Online, p. 66-67)

Contours of praxeological deconstructionism: research programme54

It remains problematic to think along the lines of the strict distinction Robert Cox makes between problem-solving or rationalist theories and critical or interpretivist theories of IR because in essence ‘[all] theory is political and [all] political action is theory-laden’.55 The rigidity that comes with the two main approaches, or ‘theoretical churches’, does no specific good to the field in general. While there is dignity in difference, there is hope in some degree of commonality. The approach being promoted here is more congenial to critical theory thanks to its reflexivity but it also embraces mixed methods. The quest is to problematise the ‘problem-solving/critical theory’ binary that we have been presented with in the field of IR, based on the argument that it is arbitrary and often a misrepresentation of the many theories and research traditions that often attempt to exhibit both characteristics. In some cases what is considered to be solving a problem actually solves nothing, since the theory can be so removed from the world ‘out there’ that it attempts to describe, revealing an overpowering ‘practicality deficit’ in the theory’s core assumptions.56

My proposition for a ‘third way’ is based on these premises: First, historically some critical theorists have borrowed from problem-solving theorists, and vice [end page 66] versa. For instance, a feminist theorist like Ann Tickner has attempted to reformulate realism.57 While there are many variants of feminism, some of them appear to begin their theorising with an acknowledgement of traditional realists such as Hans Morgenthau.58 The point here is that some critical theories seem to have built upon some of the assumptions of problem-solving theories, although others deconstruct and reject them outright. After all, Cynthia Enloe has argued that a book about international politics should leave one with a sense that ‘I can do something’, a more instrumental and affirmative orientation that most IR books lack.59

Let me note at this point that I find this approach receptive to the kind of scholarship being pursued by some critical feminist scholars. Such scholars have been successful at borrowing from problem-solving theories, yet still with a quest for progressive change. In their analysis of social movements, for instance, Meyer and Lupo argue that feminism’s uniqueness derives from its ability to consistently illuminate the relationship between self and community.60 Critical feminist scholarship is interested in processes of domination that are often silenced by the mainstream’s fetishism with the state, power and anarchy, a commitment that results from the ‘lived injustices’ or sufferings of marginalised groups.61 Thus, feminist scholars’ commitment to emancipatory politics is ‘aimed at transforming relations of inequality and domination’.62 Additionally, feminist scholars have carefully examined the concept of intersectionality, which mainly emphasises the interwoven nature of race, class, gender and sexuality in order to show the mutually constitutive nature of identity and structures of inequality.63 And ‘because intersectional knowledge is grounded in everyday lives of people of diverse backgrounds, it is seen as an important tool linking theory with practice’.64 These ‘feminist characteristics’ are elements that the approach espoused below identifies with and, in fact, I hope that the notion of PD will encourage discussions among scholars interested in progressive social change through research. As some critical scholars are already doing, we should particularly ask: ‘how should we do our research in order to increase the likelihood that it will actually help make the world a better place?’.65

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.