No neg offense — critical theory and problem-solving theory aren’t mutually exclusive.
Andrews 13 — Nathan Andrews, Trudeau and Vanier Scholar in the Department of Political Science at the University of Alberta (Canada), former Banting Postdoctoral Fellow at Queen's University (Canada), holds a Ph.D in Political Science from the University of Alberta (Canada), 2013 (“Beyond the Ivory Tower: A Case for ‘Praxeological Deconstructionism’ as a ‘Third Way’ in IR Theorising,” Third World Quarterly, Volume 34, Number 1, Available Online to Subscribing Institutions via Taylor & Francis Online, p. 59-60)
International Relations (IR) theory is typically divided into two: traditional (often known as problem-solving/rationalist) theory and critical (often referred to as reflectivist/interpretivist) theory. Traditional theories remain the most predominant in the field of study as they often have powerful proponents and a larger number of disciples. The Oxford English Dictionary defines tradition as ‘a long established and generally accepted custom or method of procedure, having almost the force of a law’.3 In this context anything ‘traditional’ is ‘observant [end page 59] of, bound by tradition’.4 The origins of the theories are what make them cohere as traditional theories of IR and include realism (neorealism and critical realism); the English School; and liberal theories (liberalism, neoliberalism, global governance and cosmopolitanism). These are theories that often dwell on ancient and classical writings from Aristotle to Voltaire, and are sometimes committed to (re)interpreting these writings as though they were written for this contemporary age. They are also traditional because they possess the force of law where, for instance, the ‘realist gambit’5 has been dominant as well as the (neo)liberal ‘common-sense’.6
Theories considered to be critical include feminism, post-structuralism, securitisation and postcolonialism, among others. The question then is: what makes them ‘critical’? As Steven Roach asserts, ‘what makes critical IR theory “critical” is its self-awareness as a theory’—an awareness woven into the critical traditions of Kant, Hegel, Marx, Habermas, Derrida and Butler7—and we can certainly add Michel Foucault among other post-Enlightenment French philosophers. It is argued that critical theory was introduced into IR in 1981 with the publication of Robert Cox’s Social Forces, States and World Orders and Richard K Ashley’s Political Realism and Human Interests.8 A discussion of the so-called ‘great debates’ will show that critical theorists are generally post- positivist and to a large extent anti-foundationalist in that they do not accept any objective, Archimedean point or standard by which ‘legitimate’ knowledge should be measured. And they are also postmodern in the sense that they oppose the teleological measurement of human progress that characterises Enlightenment thinking, in addition to their quest to deconstruct established interpretations (discourse) in order to ascertain their embedded ‘silences’. It is based on this common ontological and epistemological orientation that neo- Gramscian theory and deconstructionism manage to fit under critical IR theory.
The problem, however, is that couching the broader field into two binaries— what Cox in 1981 classified as problem-solving and critical theory, respectively—is a problematic simplification of the discussion of international relations. Although many people will agree that there is no pure form of these two main schools, some IR textbooks, course syllabuses and journal articles perpetuate this trend.9 This configuration of the field inhibits the multidimensional nature of the subject matter. In an attempt to reconcile the binary between problem-solving (rationalist) theories and critical (interpretivist) theory, this paper also tries to construct what can be considered a ‘third way’ in IR theorising for those who seek to transcend what is usually characteristic of either of these theoretical traditions. The crux of the entire paper is to explain why the contention here is to adopt a ‘third way’ (what I refer to as ‘praxeological deconstructionism’10) as opposed to the rationalist and reflectivist/interpretivist schools in IR theory. The quest is to make the discipline practically relevant in explaining the ‘here and now’ while not abandoning the need to be critical and self-reflexive in its theorising. Overall the paper initiates a purposive call for the dual goal of deconstruction and reconstruction, a normative and instrumental position that the ‘thick descriptions’ of most critical theorists (particularly those belonging to the ‘post-’ approaches) often fail to emphasise.11