There’s no essential incompatibility between securitization and transformation – adding the ALT overcomes residual links, or it was never effective in the first place
Loader 7 Ian Loader, Professor of Criminology and Director of the Centre for Criminology at the University of Oxford; and Neil Walker, Professor of European Law in the Department of Law at the European University Institute, and the Tercentenary Professor of Law at the University of Edinburgh; Civilizing Security, Cambridge University Press, 2007, ISBN 978-0-511-28506-6, pp.89-93 /GoGreen!
These critical observations on the current security constellation impart some valuable warnings, some of which, as noted, are shared by liberal critics of the ‘war on terror’. They suggest, first and foremost, that democratic societies risk spiralling into a vicious circle of terror–fear–repression whose all too likely consequence is the erosion, perhaps even demise, of democratic government and the rule of law (Rorty 2004). As political elites respond to acts of terror with ‘security measures’ that seek to assuage public insecurity (and anger) by further empowering police and military institutions, they do several things: not only do they direct the resources of the partisan state at already often unpopular and over-policed minority populations (both at home and abroad); they also institutionalize public anxiety in ways that make it difficult to envisage cultural conditions that will permit ‘temporary’ exceptional measures to be repealed, and leave themselves with little practical choice but to respond to the next terrorist attack with yet more – still tougher – ‘security solutions’. As each ‘ordering measure brings into being new ambiguities and ambivalences which call for further measures, the chase never ends’ (Bauman and Tester 2001: 79; see, also, Dillon 1996: 127).
For liberals the practical task is to find ways of responding to terror (and the fear and loathing that it generates, or reinforces, or renews) in ways that break out of this insecurity-heightening, democracy-corroding spiral (see, for example, Ackerman 2004; Ignatieff 2004; Dyzenhaus and Hunt forthcoming). This too, more broadly, is the impulse that informs this book – one that holds that it is possible in this field to envisage and create virtuous circles that both civilize security and release the civilizing potential of security. The variant of state scepticism we have been concerned with here presses, however, a more disquieting claim – one that presents a serious critique of such possibilities. From this perspective there is no obvious route away from a world in which exceptionalism has become what Agamben (2004a: 2 and passim) calls ‘the dominant paradigm of government in contemporary politics’ – and certainly not one which travels under the banner of security. We are faced with what looks set to become an unceasing war against terror in which partisan, exceptional states name and chase new enemies, fortify borders as they violate them, suspend law in the name of law, and undermine democracy in an effort to save it. How, in such a world, the leftist state sceptic asks, can we speak meaningfully about, let alone begin to construct, a socially coherent project of collective security?
Against security?
The strands of radical thought outlined in this chapter offer a cogent critique of the state and its securitizing practices. It is a critique that appears able to capture important aspects of a historical record that has seen states time and again, in both authoritarian and democratic contexts, allocate the benefits and burdens of policing in ways that systematically protect the security interests of powerful constituencies at the expense of those of the poor and dispossessed. It supplies, in addition, a cogent account of the dangers of placing security at the ideological heart of government, of the capacity of security politics to colonize public policy and pervade social life in ways that threaten democratic values and sustain fear-laden, other-disregarding forms of political subjectivity and collective identity. In these respects, this variant of state scepticism offers a critique of the operation and effects of state power that in many significant respects we share (N. Walker 2000; Loader 2002). But it also poses what are undoubtedly some profound challenges to the position we wish here to construct and defend. If we are to make a persuasive case for both the good of security, and the indispensability of the state to the production of that good, then we need to find a means of rising to them.
These objections then are far from trivial, and we have not devoted this chapter to them simply in order to knock them down. But they nonetheless arise from a standpoint that is not itself without shortcomings, as we hope to show in meeting them. As a prelude to the more sustained effort along these lines that we offer in part II, let us consider briefly what these shortcomings are. For analytic purposes, they may usefully be put into three groups.
This radical variant of state scepticism tends, first of all, to underplay the openness of political systems and the theoretical and political prospects that this affords. It displays, in particular, a structural fatalism that overlooks the overlap between the production of specific and general order, such that disadvantaged groups and communities have a considerable stake not only in controlling state power, but also in using public resources (including policing resources) as a means of generating more secure forms of economic and social existence. It also remains insufficiently attentive to how the mix between general and specific order (the extent, in other words, to which policing is shaped by common as well as factional interests) is conditioned by political struggle and the varieties of institutional settlement to which this gives rise, thereby varying over time and between polities. Much the same point, moreover, can be directed at the radical critique of the violence that underpins liberal political orders that aim to be free of such violence. One finds here a quite proper insistence on the troubling conundrum that democratic polities ultimately depend upon coercion to enforce collective decisions and protect democratic institutions. But this point is hammered home in terms that are overly sweeping and reductionist – often, as in the writings of Agamben (2004a), as a philosophical claim that invites but resists sociological scrutiny. If ‘there is always a violence at the heart of every form of political and legal authority’ (Newman 2004: 575), upon what grounds can we distinguish between, or develop a critique of, the security-seeking practices of particular states – and why would we bother?
Radical anti-statism evinces, secondly, a preference for social and political criticism over social and political reconstruction. It favours a politics that privileges the monitoring, exposure and critique of the systematic biases of state power (as, for instance, in the indefatigable efforts of the British-based NGO Statewatch), one that implicitly or expressly holds that ‘security’ is so stained by its uncivil association with the (military and police) state that the only available radical strategy is to destabilize the term itself, while contesting the practices that are enacted under its name (Dalby 1997: 6; see, also, Dillon 1996: ch. 1). There can, from this vantage point, be no progressive democratic politics aimed at civilizing security. Rather, one is left with a politics of critique, and a failure of political imagination, that leaves radically underspecified the feasible or desirable alternatives to current institutional configurations and practices, or else merely gestures towards the possibility of transcendent forms of non-state communal ordering – as in George Rikagos’s (2002: 150) claim that ‘the only real alternatives to current policing practices are pre-capitalist, non-commodified security arrangements’.
Finally, one finds what we think of as a one-sided appraisal of the sources of inequality and insecurity in the world today. This leftist anti-statist sensibility tends, in the ways we have demonstrated, towards an account of social injustice that views it as the product of the state’s malign and coercive interventions rather than of its impotence and neglect. Here one finds a curious parallel with the neo-liberalism considered in the last chapter – the state remains the problem. But one also encounters a critique of security politics that views it as tied to the production of authoritarian government – as if security is in some essential fashion inimical to democracy and human rights. Here the radical critic begins to inhabit similar ground to that occupied by what we characterized in chapter 1 as the ‘security lobby’. They assess the landscape very differently and commit to diametrically opposed political purposes. But they cling commonly and tenaciously to the belief that security stands opposed to liberty.
Our aim, in part II, is to move beyond these positions and oppositions: first, by retrieving the idea of security as a public good that is axiomatic both to the production of other goods (most directly, liberty) and to the constitution of democratic political communities; second, by arguing that the production of this good demands not the wholesale critique and transcendence of state forms, but more robust regulatory interventions by democratized state institutions. We must first, however, factor into our positive case two further critiques of the state, starting with the claim that it is a cultural monolith.