Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO isn’t going anywhere – refusal to participate doesn’t solve any of their impacts – nor do anything about emerging tech; regardless of the goal, security cooperation is a superior method to achieve it than NOT

Gilli 20 Andrea Gilli, Senior Researcher at the NATO Defense College, former visiting and postdoctoral fellow at Stanford University, Johns Hopkins University, Columbia University, and Harvard University, ““NATO-mation”: preparing for technological transformation,” Chapter 2, “NATO-Mation”: Strategies for Leading in the Age of Artificial Intelligence, NDC Research Paper No.15, December 2020, pp.25-26 /GoGreen!

What are the implications of the growing capabilities and dissemination of AI, ML and BD for NATO? Is the Atlantic Alliance powerless when faced with this wave of technological change, or could it adopt some measures to handle and address the ensuing challenges and opportunities? And what should Allies do? Should they pursue arms control or promote research and development, address legal and ethical questions, or just focus on the tactical integration of these new technologies? How can the Allies exploit their combined, but diverse, set of skills, capabilities and experiences so as to harness the power of AI?

Building on the previous discussion of AI as a GPT, it appears that the challenge for NATO is subtle, multifaceted and significant. First, in an age of accelerating technological change and growing domain applicability, catching up with industry leaders and innovators becomes more and more difficult for those that lag behind.73 This means that waiting is not a solution – even though acting prematurely, in a realm of great uncertainty, is inherently difficult and risky.74 Second, governments cannot expect that individuals, firms and organizations will be able to embrace and successfully exploit the new wave of technological transformation alone, without advice, support, direction, vision or investments in infrastructure. Third, while some countries will have an advantage, others will find the transition more difficult. Regardless of this, technological transitions do not occur in a vacuum, as they require the alignment of incentives among a multiplicity of actors, organizations and institutions, as well as the provision of complementary services and goods for the new technologies to flourish and be adopted.75 Fourth, and more important for NATO, without coordinating and cooperating on their investments in the necessary complementary assets, goods and services, Allies could find themselves having to face additional hurdles.

What types of problem could emerge? Technology-generated efficiency gains in production lead to lower prices. However, lower prices lead to increases in demand – because the relative price of substitute goods (rivals) increases.76 Over the past decade, AI – and, in particular, ML – has made a particular activity, prediction, cheaper: it is reasonable to forecast that this trend will continue in the future.77 As AI becomes cheaper, however, the demand for AI-related services will increase, thus leading to more demand for related necessities like AI specialists, AI infrastructure (and 5G networks) and AI components (processors). This in turn might well lead to scarcity and higher prices, thus pitching actors against one another – not unlike the early stages of the COVID-19 crisis, when individual self-interested actions led to collectively bad outcomes.78 In the context of a military alliance, the problem goes much deeper, as it can generate a beggar-thy-neighbour effect with allies competing for the same scarce resources.79 Moreover, without consultation and cooperation, Allies could end up developing different technological solutions, with the risk of undermining compatibility and interoperability. Similarly, they could end up prioritizing some problems over others, with the risk of developing multiple, different and redundant solutions while neglecting other points in need of attention.80 However, through intra-alliance coordination and cooperation, as well as dialogue and consultation, secondary market mechanisms and other approaches, NATO could provide an important contribution to identify and address this type of problems.81

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.