The scientific truths that undergird our scholarship are real – poststructuralism is coopted by corporations and post-truth politicians to worse material effect than anything we said and turns ALT solvency
Gómez-Baggethun 20 Erik Gómez-Baggethun, Department of International Environment and Development Studies (Noragric), Faculty of Landscape and Society, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, and Norwegian Institute for Nature Research, “More is more: Scaling political ecology within limits to growth,” Political Geography, vol.76, January 2020, DOI 10.1016/j.polgeo.2019.102095 /GoGreen!
Half a century ago, constructionist claims played an important role in critical scholarship, showing how analytical categories we take for granted as universal truths did not exist in other times and places, and exposing how these categories were exploited by elites to exercise power (e.g. Foucault, 1971). Authors like Wittgenstein, Benveniste and Lacan exposed the articulations between language and the way we understand reality, putting into question dominant forms of realism that magnified the absolute and universal character of scientific truths. In this line of reasoning, intellectuals associated with postmodern1 and post-structuralist thinking, like Barthes, Derrida, Kristeva, Foucault, Deleuze, Baudrillard, Jameson, and Lyotard challenged established beliefs surrounding scientific panaceas and the dogmas of modernity. In doing so they contributed to erode beliefs in certainties, allegedly emanating from reason, that shielded the exercise of power by endowing it with the unquestionable authority of scientific truth.
The deconstructionist machinery set in motion by these authors, however, soon proved double edged. Naïve realism –the original target of this criticism– fell in disgrace and social constructionism gradually became the mainstream in cultural studies. Eventually, and with some support of the media, vulgarized variants of this criticism contributed to expand a generalized climate of moral relativism, skepticism and cynicism that, in words by Lévy (1987: 20), installed us in an obsessively modest way of thinking that makes of uncertainty its last word, and which ‘extreme relativism has resulted in a generalized idiocy’ (cited in Naredo, 2015). In another critical account Sahlins (2002: 49) notes that ‘one of the more poignant aspects of the current postmodernist mood is the way it seems to lobotomize some of our best graduate students, to stifle their creativity for fear of making some interesting structural connection […] or a comparative generalization. The only safe essentialism left to them is that there is no order to culture’. Critics suggest that epistemic relativisms that reduce interpretations of reality to mere ‘narratives’, ‘discourses’ and ‘social constructs’ have been instrumental for today’s generalized skepticism and cynicism (Boghossian, 2007; Sokal & Bricmont, 1999; Zerzan, 1994). Naredo (2015) further notes that this epistemic climate, initially conceived as a healthy critique to established ideas, later came to be exploited by the status quo to mask the dark sides of progress –such as environmental destruction from economic growth–, behind a nebulous of uncertainty. Decades of scholarship devoted to deconstruct ‘truth’ paved the way for a golden era of relativism. Post-truth, a concept used to describe the disappearance of shared objective standards for truth and the undifferentiated blurring of facts, values, knowledge, opinion, and belief that characterizes today’s intellectual climate (Biesecker, 2018), may be looked at as the ultimate Frankenstein of this epistemological drift. According to Frankfurt (2005: 16), –who foresaw the post-truth coming long ago: ‘The contemporary proliferation of bullshit has deeper sources in various forms of skepticism which deny that we can have any reliable access to an objective reality’.
Today this intellectual climate is successfully exploited by business power that, in the name of progress and growth, manufacture doubt and uncertainty to prevent the precautionary principle and undermine environmental regulations (Harremo€es et al., 2013; Michaels & Jones, 2005; Oreskes & Conway, 2010). In an era of ecological breakdown and post-truth, caricaturizing limits as fanaticism (Bruckner, 2013; Phillips, 2015) or banalizing their relevance as mere ‘constructs’ or ‘discourses’, serves the denialism of corporate power and the new authoritarianism. To Latour’s assertion that ‘context stinks’ (2005: 148, citing Koolhaas), in today’s post truth era time may be ripe to add that ‘(de)constructionism stinks’ too.