Securitization theory does NOT explain Russia
van der Laan 16 Mark van der Laan, MA candidate, International Studies, Universiteit Leiden, BA History, University of Amsterdam, “Between a Rock and a Hard Place: A Security Dilemma in the Baltics?” MA thesis, 10-12-2016, https://www.academia.edu/29525112/BETWEEN_A_ROCK_AND_A_HARD_PLACE_A_Security_Dilemma_in_the_Baltics /GoGreen!
The main theoretical underpinning of this thesis is, as mentioned before, that of securitisation. 13 The interesting point about this theory as explained by Wæver and others, is that takes a post-modern approach to security. Primarily that a discourse about security can enforce a reality. To specify this to Russian foreign policy, when NATO is seen as the primary adversary, every action by the alliance, such stationing military units Eastern Europe to reassure allies and deter possible military actions, can be viewed as a threat to Russian security concerns. Or as Sergey Karaganov, head of the Council on Foreign and Defense Policy, puts it in an interview with Der Spiegel, ‘Now, fears in countries like Poland, Lithuania and Latvia are to be allayed by NATO stationing weapons there. But that doesn't help them; we interpret that as a provocation. In a crisis, we will destroy exactly these weapons. Russia will never again fight on its own territory…’14 It must be stressed though that this securitisation debate in this case is not sole a Russian purview. In response to Russian actions taken in Ukraine, and the several large military exercises in the Russian Western Military District, a securitisation debate is taking place in the West. One outcome of this debate were the NATO Summits of 2014, and 2016 which were explicitly concerned with coming up with a response to Russian military aggression.15 Therein lies also a weakness for the securitisation theory. If two narratives are put beside each other, and are then argued to be a discourse, then we might arguably state a false equivalency about the two narratives. While the Russian narrative in regard to the West, is arguably a constructed view of the world, Western concerns about Russian behaviour are arguably justified and a response to Russian aggression. In other words, we must discern fact from bullshit, as Harry Frankfurt put in his article On Bullshit.16 While it can be argued that the current security situation is a construct, this construct has implications in the real world. How did this construct came into being? It can be argued that President Putin’s notion that the collapse of the Soviet as one of the greatest geopolitical disasters of the twentieth century is not without merit.17 If we view the collapse of the Soviet Union as a collapse of an imperial power, Putin’s argument is understandable. Decolonisation can be a traumatic experience, for both the coloniser, and the colonised. The example of how France fought two destructive wars in Algeria and Indochina reminds us, shows that this can be the case. However, how both parties interact with one another after the dust has settled can do much to normalise relations between the two. For much of the past twenty-six years, it seemed that new geopolitical situation in Central and Eastern Europe was a fait accompli. Which was reinforced by several treaties signed in the first decade after the collapse of the Soviet Union. Treaties like the Budapest Memorandum18 and the NATO-Russia Founding Act19 in 1994, and 1997 respectively. Even the advent of President Putin as prime minister, and later as president, gave no indication of major shifts in Russian foreign policy behaviour. While there were tensions in the way NATO resolved the several Balkan conflicts, one would have to be clairvoyant, or extremely pessimistic to predict the current security situation in Europe. Yet, in 2008 with the five-day war against Georgia, and the annexation of Crimea and starting a war in Donbas in 2014, Western governments were confronted by a Russia, willing to bare its teeth to gain a geopolitical advantage. The timing of these actions are arguably well planned. Russia, having invested heavily in upgrading its armed forces, giving it a comparative advantage militarily. This development caught European governments on a vulnerable moment, which issued condemnatory declarations, but lacked substantial tools, save economic sanctions, to give teeth to those condemnations. Due to systemic defence budget cuts in the past twentysix years. Undeterred, Russian sabre rattling has continued unabated.