Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Can’t repair the LIO—three reasons

John J. Mearsheimer, 2019 (professor of international relations @ Chicago, “Bound to Fail,” https://www.belfercenter.org/ publication/bound-fail-rise-and-fall-liberal-international-order, Retrieved 9/19/2021)

By 2019, it was clear that the liberal international order was in deep trouble. The tectonic plates that underpin it are shifting, and little can be done to repair and rescue it. Indeed, that order was destined to fail from the start, as it contained the seeds of its own destruction. The fall of the liberal international order horrifies the Western elites who built it and who have benefited from it in many ways.1 These elites fervently believe that this order was and remains an important force for promoting peace and prosperity around the globe. Many of them blame President Donald Trump for its demise. After all, he expressed contempt for the liberal order when campaigning for president in 2016; and since taking office, he has pur-sued policies that seem designed to tear it down. It would be a mistake, however, to think that the liberal international order is in trouble solely because of Trump’s rhetoric or policies. In fact, more funda¬mental problems are at play, which account for why Trump has been able to successfully challenge an order that enjoys almost universal support among the foreign policy elites in the West. The aim of this article is to determine why the liberal world order is in big trouble and to identify the kind of inter¬national order that will replace it. I offer three main sets of arguments. First, because states in the modern world are deeply interconnected in a variety of ways, orders are essential for facilitating efficient and timely interactions. There are different kinds of inter-national orders, and which type emerges depends primarily on the global dis-tribution of power. But when the system is unipolar, the political ideology of the sole pole also matters. Liberal international orders can arise only in unipo-lar systems where the leading state is a liberal democracy. Second, the United States has led two different orders since World War II. The Cold War order, which is sometimes mistakenly referred to as a “liberal international order,” was neither liberal nor international. It was a bounded or-der that was limited mainly to the West and was realist in all its key dimen-sions. It had certain features that were also consistent with a liberal order, but those attributes were based on realist logic. The U.S.-led post–Cold War order, on the other hand, is liberal and international, and thus differs in fundamental ways from the bounded order the United States dominated during the Cold War. Third, the post–Cold War liberal international order was doomed to col-lapse, because the key policies on which it rested are deeply flawed. Spreading liberal democracy around the globe, which is of paramount importance for building such an order, not only is extremely difficult, but often poisons rela¬tions with other countries and sometimes leads to disastrous wars. National¬ism within the target state is the main obstacle to the promotion of democracy, but balance of power politics also function as an important blocking force. Furthermore, the liberal order’s tendency to privilege international in-stitutions over domestic considerations, as well as its deep commitment to po-rous, if not open borders, has had toxic political effects inside the leading liberal states themselves, including the U.S. unipole. Those policies clash with nationalism over key issues such as sovereignty and national identity. Be¬cause nationalism is the most powerful political ideology on the planet, it in¬variably trumps liberalism whenever the two clash, thus undermining the order at its core. In addition, hyperglobalization, which sought to minimize barriers to global trade and investment, resulted in lost jobs, declining wages, and rising income inequality throughout the liberal world. It also made the international finan¬cial system less stable, leading to recurring financial crises. Those troubles then morphed into political problems, further eroding support for the liberal order.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.