2. Emerging technologies won’t lead to arms control—nations value their nuclear weapons too highly.
Michal Onderco & Madeline Zutt 21 Associate Professor, International Relations, Erasmus University Rotterdam; Research Associate, Erasmus University Rotterdam, "Emerging Technology and Nuclear Security: What Does the Wisdom of The Crowd Tell Us?" Contemporary Security Policy, Vol. 42, Issue 3, pg. 299-302, 2021, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13523260.2021.1928963, Retrieved 3/30/2022)
Table 3. Nuclear disarmament and emerging technologies. CSVDisplay Table Given that experts and policymakers agreed that emerging technologies are unlikely to carry out strategic tasks, it is perhaps not surprising that they also believed that emerging technologies are unlikely to supplant nuclear weapons. This is reflected in the fact that most experts disagreed that complete nuclear disarmament would occur when leaders believe emerging technologies will make nuclear weapons unnecessary. This finding strongly suggests that the value of nuclear weapons goes beyond their roles as deterrents. Some decision-makers agreed, noting that not only are nuclear weapons the “ultimate security guarantor” (Interviewee F) but they are also seen as a guarantor of independence and sovereignty (Interviewee B). These views support the existing literature: Scholars have long recognized the symbolic value of nuclear weapons, going well beyond their military utility (Abraham, 1998; Harrington de Santana, 2009; Hecht, 2012; Sagan, 1996). The view that emerging technologies are unlikely to supplant nuclear weapons also reflects the difficulty of verifying and monitoring the nuclear weapon ban. These difficulties have been broadly recognized. Some scholars are positive about the potential future normative developments (Considine, 2019; Egeland, 2018; Ritchie, 2019), others see risks associated with looking at the nuclear weapon ban and disarmament from an arms control perspective (Onderco, 2017; Müller, 2020).