Democratic peace theory is flawed:
Kathrine Lane, 7/21/2020 (Government Contract Specialist Coordinator at Insight Global, “Flawed Logic of Democratic Peace Theory: Summary,” https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/flawed-logic-democratic-peace-theory-summary-kathrine-lane, Retrieved 8/4/2021)
The article “Flawed Logic of Democratic Peace Theory” by Sebastian Rosato, offers a new perspective on the logic behind the democratic peace theory. The author first explains the literal definition behind the theory itself. Theorist believe that with the increase of democracies, there will be a decrease of the probability of war. They also believe that it is important to spread the ideology of democracy. Reason for decrease of war relies on two main factors: norm-externalization and trust and respect. Meaning that because they trust and respect other democracies, they are willing to work with each other to mend any conflicts. Rosato debunks this myth by providing historical examples like the Cold War and the Great Powers. The Democratic Peace Theory continues on to explain that non-democratic countries are neither trusted or respected. Non-democratic countries are not respected because their domestic system is deemed unjust in the eyes of democracies. “Extreme lack of public respect or trust is one of the major features that distinguishes re- lations between liberal and nonliberal societies from relations among liberal societies.” In addition, nondemocratic countries are often more likely to extract power by attacking or using harsh forces. An important yet tragic example of this was displayed in Tiananmen Square in China. War was another topic that Rosato related democratic peace theory to. Rosato explained that democratic countries will often fight non-democratic counties but they still remain at peace with one another. Democratic Peace Theory also claims that there are far fewer reasons to go to war when there are more democracies but it’s important to note that they justify war in cases where their country’s safety is at risk. Rosato debunks this claim by mentioning Germany and the United States conflict in World War II. As Germany progressively changed their beliefs and policies, the relationship between Germany and the United States started to diminish. American leaders justified the war on Germany because they stopped viewing Germany as a democracy. This contradicts the claim of the Democratic Peace Theory. This proves that whether or not a country was a democracy was not a determinant for foreign affairs and relations. This also proves that there is no clear definition of a true “democratic” country because affairs and opinions are constantly changing. Rosato provides concrete details that war and opposing opinions are going to occur whether or not a country is a democracy. No two countries are in fact the exactly the same, therefore they will not always come to an equal verdict on issues, causing a repercussion that sometimes lead to war, famine or new polices implemented. Personally, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this article, in fact it is one of my favorites. The theory of democratic peace comes from an idea with historical background. As a logical thinker, I enjoy looking at supporting evidence when forming an opinion. Thus, I enjoyed hearing Rosato argument. Rosato used many cases of historical evidence to support his claim that the Democratic Peace Theory has no true supporting evidence. I also enjoyed how he mentioned that public opinion is not a determinate on whether or not democracies will go to war, because if democracies did care about public opinion then they would care about being peaceful and having good relationships with all countries not just other democracies. This is an interesting point but also very valid. Often times democratic countries only communicate with other democratic counties, and if they do communicate with nondemocratic counties, they do it in an effort of forcing their views on other countries. Two great examples of this that I can think of are Vietnam and more recently in Libya.