No India-Israel-U.S. Alliance Net-Benefit — competing foreign policy interests make trilateral defense cooperation impossible.
Kamal 22 — Hassan M. Kamal, Assistant Editor at the Associated Broadcasting Company (India), 2022 (“Explained: Why the new grouping I2U2 is not a West Asian Quad,” News 9, July 14th, Available Online at https://www.news9live.com/world/explained-why-the-new-grouping-i2u2-is-not-a-west-asian-quad-182479, Accessed 07-15-2022)
For the India-Israel-UAE-US alliance to be equated with the Quad, the I2U2 bloc must agree to work together on defence and security, which seems unlikely given the members' competing interests.
The heads of states of India, Israel, the UAE and the US will come together for the first virtual summit of a new bloc known by the moniker I2U2 today. The 'I' stands for Israel and India while the 'U' stands for the UAE and the US.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Prime Minister of Israel Yair Lapid, President of the UAE Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan and US President Joseph R Biden will take part in the meeting. Modi and Sheikh Mohammed will attend the summit virtually while Biden and Lapid will be physically present for the meeting.
The I2U2 grouping was conceptualised during the meeting of the foreign ministers of the four countries held on October 18, 2021.
The group has emerged as the talking point amid changing global politics. The participating nations have termed it a purely economic group with focussed cooperation in six mutually recognised areas such as water, energy, transportation, space, health, and food security. However, some experts have dubbed the meet as West Asia 'Quad', despite the fact that existing geopolitical realities work against such nomenclature. Here's why:
Disagreement over Iran, China and Russia
In the ever-changing global politics where national interests seem to be the driving factor of foreign policy, the I2U2 comes across as a collection of unlikely countries whose current foreign policies, if continued, will create divisions rather than unify them. Among the many key foreign policy issues that divide the group are how to deal with Russia, China and Iran.
The Russia question: Though the US has reiterated that the global food crisis in the backdrop of the Ukraine conflict is going to be one of the main topics of the I2U2, the US is likely to find itself isolated in convincing the other members that Russia is behind the global food crisis.
Apart from the US, none of the other three countries in the I2U2 — Israel, India and the UAE — have followed the Western steps in imposing sanctions on Russia. In fact, they have continued to maintain "good" ties with Moscow. India specifically has increased its oil purchases to tide over the high fuel prices. India has also abstained from voting on either UN or UNSC resolutions against Russia.
Israel, in the meanwhile, has refused to sell its Iron Dome System to Ukraine to protect Ukrainian cities and military establishments from Russian attacks despite US approval.
The UAE, too, has abstained from voting against Russia in the UNSC resolutions and has even welcomed Russian oligarchs in the country.
The China Question: The US and India, who are members of the Quad Security Dialogue, a grouping dubbed as an anti-China alliance, are bringing two important nations of West Asia — Israel and UAE — to form a unique West Asian bloc. However, while the Quad's primary objective is to work for a "free, open, prosperous and inclusive Indo-Pacific region," the I2U2 focus is limited to economic collaborations in areas such as water, energy, transportation, space, health, and food security.
The chances of any collaborations in terms of defence and security, which would qualify to term the bloc as a West Asian 'Quad' seem nil. The UAE is already a part of China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) while Israel has been benefitting from the ban on US tech imports to China. It also hopes to benefit from the BRI and act as a connecting point between Europe and Asia. So, neither the UAE nor Israel stands to benefit from any efforts at containing China's influence in the region.
The Iran question: Israel says India will strengthen the impact of the Abraham Accords, but it has also made it clear that it is against Iran. The two countries are involved in a proxy war for decades with Iran supporting the Palestine Movement. The Abraham Accords, on the other hand, are a worry for Iran as it has reduced the distance between the Israeli Army and the Iranian border. The accords also allow other West Asian nations to purchase American weapons they couldn't access earlier.
Iran's proxy war against the UAE and Saudi Arabia is also a known fact. Both the UAE and Saudi Arabia, who are friends with India, regularly face drone attacks by Iran-backed Houthis in Yemen.
Despite the complexities of the region, India has managed to maintain good ties with West Asian countries, especially Iran. New Delhi is unlikely to break those ties and join an alliance against Tehran. And for good reasons.
India breaking ties with Iran will benefit China, which has signed a 25-year cooperation deal with Tehran. It would also mean New Delhi abandoning investments in the Chabahar port and other infrastructure projects.
The eastern section of the North-South corridor in Iran connecting Russia to India via Iranian rail has become operational. The first rail transit carrying 39 containers from Russia reached Iran on Tuesday. According to a report in Tehran Times, the cargo will be transported to Bandar Abbas port in southern Iran through a 1,600 km rail route to finally be sent to India's Nhava Sheva Port in Navi Mumbai via sea.
India is one of the largest investors in the Iranian oil and gas industry as well. As Talmeez Ahmed, India's former ambassador to Saudi Arabia, recently told PTI, "There is no way India will join an alliance against Iran."