A. Link — closer India-Israel cooperation on defense innovation causes a security dilemma, accelerates the arms race, and destabilizes South Asia.
Sultaana 21 — Saddaf Sultaana, Ph.D. Candidate in the Strategic Studies Department at the National Defence University (Pakistan), 2021 (“India-Israel Defence Cooperation: Security Implications for Pakistan,” Journal of Security & Strategic Analyses, Volume 7, Number 1, Available Online at http://thesvi.org/ojs/index.php/ojs/article/view/131/93, Accessed 07-18-2022, p. 156-160)
India-Israel Defence Ties: Security Implications for Pakistan
The defence and military partnership of India and Israel seems to be enduring because of their mutual strategic interests and continuous collaboration. Israel is facilitating India to acquire requisite defence equipment’s, defence production capability and upgraded weapons to maintain their alliance and sustain its ambition to be a major regional as well as a global power. Sophistication in military technology with the help of Israel and the allocation of high budget for defence purpose indicates that India wants to counter the joint threat of Pakistan and China. Hence, India’s regional and global hegemonic approach and growing defence cooperation with Israel is not only destabilizing the regional strategic balance but also carries severe consequences for the stability of South Asian region. Their clandestine relations during the Cold-War era and strong alliance after the Cold-War period proved to be a potential threat especially for Pakistan’s security. India’s obsession with power projection against strategically compatible Pakistan and strong rival China tempts it to find a reliable defence partner and Israel comes in handy.
In the last two decades, India has strengthened its defence partnership with Israel by pursuing military modernization. Timothy Hoyt writes that “military modernization is most advanced in states which are deeply involved in regional political-military rivalries, or which boast significant military and economic advantage over most of their neighbors. Many developing states face potential external threats, from regional neighbors or outside forces. These threats usually create a demand for advanced military capabilities and an [end page 156] expanded military-industrial base.”79 Therefore, to enhance its operational and deployment capabilities, India is continuously procuring advanced missile defence system, sophisticated delivery mechanism and advanced nuclear technology, which is ultimately raising the “level of threat, insecurity and arms race in the region. Various agreements on missile and defence cooperation with Israel have definitely enhanced military superiority of India while disintegrating the balance of power and compeling Pakistan to allocate extra resources on the defence sector.80 Also, the development in air, naval, satellite and space program has provided India with a strategic gain over Pakistan.
Moreover, the surveillance equipment (i.e., UAVs, cross-border sensors, and Airborne Early Warning” Systems), which India is getting from Israel,81 would help India in carrying out swift and quick operations or strikes against Pakistan and to infiltrate Pakistan’s territory. February 2019 Balakot crisis between India and Pakistan is a recent example that determines the pace of India-Israel defence partnership in which India used Israeli weapons to launch strikes inside Pakistan’s territory.82 Such incident only increases the chances of war between both the states albeit limited, intensify threat matrix for Pakistan and destabilize the peace and stability in the region.” Robert Fisk clearly stated that the defence ties between India and Israel have strengthened in the past few years which include sophisticated training [end page 157] and arms trade. According to him, “Israel has been assiduously lining itself up alongside India’s national BJP government...while India itself has now become the largest weapons market for the Israeli arms trade.”83 Hence, India-Israel strategic and defence partnership is an existential threat to the national security of Pakistan and affecting regional security calculus as well.
For India, who is dreaming to become an “Asian giant,” Israeli military technology and security cooperation provides it with the finest way to cope with its security issues. Governed by geostrategic and geopolitical priorities, the strategic partnership with Israel is enabling India to attain its greatest policy objectives, i.e. to gain regional hegemony. It is being ensured by strengthening its defence sector, to expand its military power beyond its region. The goals are wide-ranging and also include geo-economic objective, blocking Pakistan’s access to and undermine its influence in the Middle East and Central Asian states. It seeks to ultimately destabilize and weaken Pakistan’s defensive balance capability both at the eastern and western front and counter China’s influence in the region. India aspires to annex the illegally occupied Kashmiri territory following Israel’s annexation policy. In short, India-Israel strategic alliance, indeed, is emerging as the major threat to strategic stability “in South Asia and carries far-reaching implications for Pakistan’s security.”
Analyzing the aspects of India-Israel growing proximity and defence ties, it is noted that the strategic equilibrium in the region is shifting in the favor of India. The progression in their relationship not only undermines the military balance of South Asia but also destabilizes the conventional balance vis-à-vis Pakistan. Harsh V. Pant stated that “the [end page 158] most immediate effects of this close defence relationship between India and Israel can be seen in Pakistan’s worry that the strategic balance in the subcontinent is fast tilting against it. It finds it difficult to match the conventional military capability of Israel-India combined.”84 Hence, the conventional and unconventional military superiority of India is helping it to establish hegemony in the region and destabilize Pakistan’s security. Moreover, India and Israel are constantly solidifying their military ties because it is not only India who is apprehensive about the nuclear arsenals of Pakistan, but Israel had also serious concerns about Pakistan’s nuclear weapons program.85 This specifies that India-Israel defence and missile cooperation is not only activating an arms race in South Asia but also destabilizing the deterrence equation besides affecting the strategic stability in the region.
Conclusion
An expansion of defence cooperation between India and Israel along with the acquisition of military and nuclear capabilities by India through its strategic partnership with Israel would not only undermine the regional balance but will also have severe consequences “for the stability of South Asia in future. This cooperation reveals India’s strong commitment to dominance and “power projection in the broader Southern Asian region that includes Indian Ocean and Malacca Straits. Moreover, India considers Pakistan and China a major irritant in its quest for hegemony. Therefore, the defence partnership with Israel is seen as the guarantee to ensuring its ambitions.
All the major arms deal with Israel including the transfer of technology and production of missiles are “part of Prime Minister Modi’s Make in India initiative.” The steady progress and cooperation [end page 159] in missile defence system with Israel under this initiative is generating a regional security dilemma by endangering the security of other states. Development and” acquisition of defence system, as well as missile proliferation, is rigorously undermining the strategic stability and has the potential to accelerate arms race in the region. In this process India seems to have ignored that its actions are worsening the security dilemma, increasing insecurity, intensifying arms race and provoking Pakistan to take countermeasures, which in turn will further deteriorate the security environment of South Asian region.