Emerging tech causes political friction
Gilli, 21 -- affiliate at CISAC and a Researcher at the NATO Defense College
[Andrea, "NATO, technological superiority, and emerging and disruptive technologies," NATO Defense College, 2021, jstor, accessed 6-4-22]
Emerging and disruptive technologies. First, the rise of several emerging and disruptive technologies — from artificial intelligence to quantum computing, hypersonic weapons to 5G networks - has led many to speculate that a new industrial revolution is coming. Whether this is correct will only be known ex post. What we do know, ex ante, is that there will be both a process of convergence among innovative countries, and a process of divergence between innovative and non-innovative countries.18 Predicting which countries will lead and which will lag is inevitably difficult. I Iowever, we can make some educated guesses about the factors that will play a key role. Because of the knowledge-intensive nature of the current technological transformation, countries excelling in R&l) and education are more likely to succeed.19 An important question concerns the ease of appropriating others’ knowledge and know-how. litis may determine the shape and intensity of international competition: if barriers to knowledge are high, the gap between the two groups will remain significant. If barriers are low, technological capabilities will be more diffused, with major implications for the structure of international politics.
Technological revolution and long-term change. Second, while the word “revolution” is often associated to sudden changes, technological revolutions have been, in reality, the product of cumulative processes.20This is because the adoption and diffusion of technolog)’ are slow and complicated, not least because of the need to invest in complementary assets. Deductive logic and available evidence about emerging and disruptive technologies suggest that their effects will be cumulative and this is particularly true for warfare.21 For instance, machine learning algorithms remain brittle and thus can be easily neutralized by enemy tactical or operational systems. Similarly, quantum computing will require major and increasing investments, and its integration into military forces will require parallel investments.
Technological transition and technology strategy. Third, given the previous two considerations, the challenge for NATO will be two-fold: 1) preserve its scientific, technological and industrial leadership in the so-called Third Industrial Revolution areas; and 2) consolidate its leadership in the so-called fourth Industrial Revolution domains. The challenge will be a delicate one to navigate. A good number of Allies is dramatically lagging behind in emerging and disruptive technologies. This technology and industrial gap is already creating political friction on issues such as taxation of digital transactions and data regulation. Without a serious attempt to modernize technologically, a two-tiered Alliance could start to take shape, and political difficulties will inevitably arise. In order to understand the challenges ahead, it is useful to look at NATO’s potential competitors.