Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US would intervene- strategic interests and Biden’s comments prove

Feng, 22 -- Newsweek contributing editor, Asia

[John Feng, "Will U.S. defend Taiwan if China invades? Experts weigh in," Newsweek, 6-1-2022, https://www.newsweek.com/us-taiwan-china-invasion-1712083, accessed 6-4-2022]

Ely Ratner, the Pentagon's assistant secretary of defense for Indo-Pacific security affairs, told a House committee hearing in March that the U.S. response in such a scenario would differ from how it's supporting Ukraine. "I'm confident that some of our closest partners would be with us in a Taiwan contingency," he said.

Last week, while standing beside Prime Minister Fumio Kishida of Japan at a press conference in Tokyo, Biden said the U.S. would become military involved in the event of a Chinese invasion, even though he believed such a move "will not happen" and "will not be attempted."

Although Biden later disagreed, his remarks appeared to break with over four decades of careful dancing around the question, a deliberate position known as "strategic ambiguity," in which the U.S. doesn't publicly commit or dismiss the possibility of defending Taiwan militarily.

The End of Ambiguity?

Taiwan, meanwhile, says it would be ready to fight alone, although it has asked the U.S. to expedite arms sales as PLA capabilities continue to grow.

While some may argue otherwise, subject matter experts believe China already assumed America would intervene, long before the president's apparent slip of the tongue.

"For Beijing, Biden's remarks may reveal the attitude to the current 'answer' to U.S. strategic ambiguity," says Hung Tzu-chieh, an assistant research fellow at the Institute for National Defense and Security Research, Taiwan's top military think tank. "I don't think Biden's remarks will change Beijing's strategic thinking, as Beijing has long considered the possibility of U.S. military intervention."

"For example, China has continued to develop its naval power and anti-access/area denial (A2/AD) capabilities in the Western Pacific over the past decades. Its purpose is mainly to target the U.S. military," Hung says.

The PLA's rapidly developing long-range strike capabilities—both conventional and nuclear—are unlikely to be used on Taiwan either, their range already capable of reaching Guam.

According to Su Tzu-yun, an associate researcher at Taipei's INDSR (Institute for National Defense and Security Research), the U.S. approach has changed. "President Biden has referenced a commitment to defend Taiwan several times," he says. "These are clear strategic signals to deter China's military adventurism."

"[U.S.] policy is clear, but its strategy is ambiguous; that is, its objective of maintaining the [Taiwan Strait] status quo is clear, but its means are flexible," Su argues.

America's Changing Sentiment Towards Taiwan

The defense analyst lists obvious geostrategic reasons for why the U.S. might want to defend Taiwan, which sits in the center of the so-called first island chain that hems in China. The sea lines around Taiwan are busy, carrying 90 percent of Japan's crude oil and 76 percent of its liquified natural gas—both major lifelines for Tokyo, Su says.

The Bashi Channel, a waterway separating Taiwan from the Philippines to its south, is also critical for the defense of the continental U.S., as Chinese submarines exiting the passage into the Western Pacific can launch ballistic missiles capable of reaching the West Coast, Su's analysis shows.

Sean King, senior vice president of New York-based Park Strategies, believes Biden's comments were sincere. "He voted for the Taiwan Relations Act in 1979 as a senator (so, he clearly understands the issue) and has now said three times that we'd defend Taiwan in case of mainland attack."

"It's not a change in U.S. policy but does signal growing American sentiment in Taiwan's favor," he said.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.