Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Post-Ukraine unity is collapsing

Ramesh, 22 -- News9 Staff

[KV, "European unity starts fraying as Ukraine War stretches past 90 days," NewsNine, 5-27-2022, https://www.news9live.com/opinion-blogs/european-unity-starts-fraying-as-ukraine-war-stretches-past-90-days-172746, accessed 6-19-2022]

European unity starts fraying as Ukraine War stretches past 90 days

With the Ukraine conflict in its ninth week, Europe’s unity shows cracks Poland lashes out at Germany on tanks, at Norway over gas prices Turkey, Hungary and Serbia project their own nationalist agendas

Even as the US tries to put up a pan-European front against Moscow, the initial unity among the EU-NATO partners born out of the shock of Russia invading Ukraine seems to be showing chinks. Countries within the EU and NATO are scuffling with each other over bilateral issues, all of which have roots in the Ukraine conflict, or have a bearing on the ongoing war. Of broken promises The latest row is between Poland and Germany, with the former accusing Berlin of reneging on an agreement to supply Warsaw with new German tanks as compensation for Polish deliveries of Soviet-era tanks to Ukraine.

Polish President Andrzej Duda on Tuesday accused Germany of breaking an agreement to supply Warsaw with new tanks as compensation for Polish deliveries of Soviet-era tanks to Ukraine, a claim rejected by Berlin. In April, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz introduced "Ringtausch," a swap scheme under which eastern NATO partners would supply the Ukrainian army with Soviet-era tanks like the T-72 in exchange for modern western tanks from German manufacturers, such as the Leopard.

Scholz argued that the arrangement would benefit Ukraine because its soldiers and mechanics are already familiar with Soviet-era tanks, while eastern NATO countries receive an upgrade for giving up their tanks. "They (the Germans) have not fulfilled this promise. And frankly, we are very disappointed about this," the Polish president told Die Welt on the sidelines of the World Economic Forum in Davos.

"We have provided Ukraine with a large number of tanks … because we believe it is our responsibility as a neighbour," Duda told the interviewer. Tanks for Ukraine According to reports, Warsaw passed on at least 240 Soviet-era tanks to the Ukrainian military. "By doing so, we depleted our own military potential and stockpiles," he argued. The German government rejected Duda's claims. "The federal government is flabbergasted, that's how I would put it," government spokesman Steffen Hebestreit said Wednesday when asked for a reaction during a press conference in Berlin.

"There was a clear request from the Polish side to transfer state-of-the-art Leopard 2A7 main battle tanks to Poland, but the problem is that the Bundeswehr itself only has a small number — about 50 — of these tanks," he said, adding that while "more are in the pipeline, they are not standing on a car yard or factory site anywhere; they have to be manufactured." Claims and counterclaims Sticking yet another knife in Berlin's side, Polish prime minister Mateusz Morawiecki criticised Chancellor Scholz for his refusal to travel to Kyiv. "I think he should do that," Morawiecki told Die Welt. He added, "There is nothing better than visiting the capital of the fighting nation to realise the seriousness of the situation, to get a sense of the importance of all that is happening there." Scholz has refused to travel to the Ukrainian capital for the moment, arguing that he had already gone there 10 days before the Russian invasion started, and would not go again "for a quick in and out with a photoshoot". "If [I go to Kyiv], then it's always about very specific things. And they have to be prepared," Scholz told German television RTL last week. German officials feel that Poland is trying to profit from its outward generosity to Kyiv. In lieu of the old Soviet-era tanks they have passed to Ukraine, the Poles are demanding that Germany recompense it with new, modern German tanks. The leaders in Warsaw seem to target everyone else in Europe, to flaunt that they have been at the forefront of the effort to support Ukraine, while other countries remained laggards. Their hostility to Putin has resulted in Russia cutting off gas supplies to Poland after the latter refused to pay for the supplies in rubles as demanded by Moscow. In frustration, Poland hit out at gas-rich Norway, a member of the EU and NATO, accusing it of profiteering from the war. On Sunday, Morawiecki claimed that Norway would earn an extra €100 billion ($106.9 billion) from energy sales this year due to a spike in oil and gas prices caused by the conflict in Ukraine and international sanctions on Russia, and demanded that the Nordic country share its bounty with Kyiv, while obliquely suggesting that his country too deserved a share. Morawiecki argued that Oslo shouldn't necessarily send its money to Poland, but to Ukraine. He even suggested that Polish students lobby with their Norwegian friends to pressure their country. Not profiteering says Norway Norway hit back, making it clear that it would not give in to Poland's demand. Norwegian Deputy Foreign Minister Eivind Vad Petersson denied that his country was profiteering from the war. He argued that the excess oil and gas revenues go into the country's pension fund, also known as the Oil Fund, which was established in 1990 to make sure that this wealth serves the current and future generations of Norwegians. Norway has arguably the best public welfare programme and social safety net in the world, financed by its hydrocarbon revenues. But the pension fund has lost 550 billion Norwegian krone (around $56 billion) due to turbulence in the stock market, Petersson said. In support of Moscow Elsewhere in Europe, countries like Hungary and Serbia maintained their countries' indirect support to Moscow. Hungarian prime minister Viktor Orban has been a firm supporter of Putin and has refused flatly to join the sanctions of the West against Russia. He has categorically refused to abide by the EU sanctions on buying gas and oil from Russia, arguing that his country just could not do without Russian fuel supplies. Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic echoed Orban's line, declaring on Wednesday that despite pressure from the EU, Belgrade would pursue its own independent policy. "Right now, there is no such possibility," Vucic informed Serbian state broadcaster RTS when asked if Serbia could impose sanctions on Moscow. Serbia has steadfastly refused to join NATO but has applied for membership in the EU. "We look out for our own interests," Vucic said. "Who knows what kind of threats we may face, but as you see, it's been 90 days and Serbia is standing by its policy, the only country in all of Europe. A small country with people small in numbers but very proud is following its own policy – not pro-Russian, not pro-Western, but its own," he pointed out. "You now talk about the territorial integrity of Ukraine, but you didn't talk that way 23 years ago," Vucic said, referring to the 1999 NATO war that led to the Serbian province of Kosovo becoming independent thanks to backing from the US and its allies. Threats from Turkey And worsening yet another headache for the EU, Turkish government spokesman Ibrahim Kalin said his government would not allow Finland and Sweden into the NATO alliance until Turkey's "concrete" security concerns regarding terrorism and sanctions are met. Kalin's remarks came at the end of five-hour-long talks between delegations from Sweden and Finland with their Turkish counterparts in Ankara to discuss their joint applications to join NATO last week. Their admission to NATO needs the unanimous consent of all 30 member states, and Turkey has threatened to block the accession process unless the two countries crackdown on groups it considers terrorists. Turkey has demanded that the two Nordic countries lift arms export restrictions on Turkey, and extradite activists of the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) and Gulen movement (FETO) who have sought haven in the two countries. The differences within the EU that have hobbled its efforts for a unified and aggressive response to the Russian invasion of Ukraine, may come to a head-on May 30 and 31, when the countries' leaders meet in a summit in Brussels. Countries express disquiet As the war in Ukraine shows signs of prolonging, voices expressing disquiet over the way the West is handling the crisis appear to be getting louder. At the EU summit, Cyprus, Italy, and Hungary are likely to table a resolution demanding a ceasefire in Ukraine and opening peace talks aimed at resolving the conflict. Tempers seem to be fraying among the allies and the verbal exchanges seem to be becoming rough, with Ukraine brusquely dismissing a suggestion by Henry Kissinger that Ukraine's borders be set at the pre-invasion status quo. Ukraine demands that the Russian forces withdraw to the pre-2014 level. Kissinger's suggestion is more in line with the Russian recognition of the rebel provinces of Donetsk and Lugansk as independent republics. Addressing the World Economic Forum in Davos, Kissinger suggested that Ukraine give up the two provinces to buy lasting peace with Russia. He said further alienation of Russia might force it to become a strong and permanent ally of China, endangering global security. Ukrainian presidential adviser Alexey Arestovich flew off the handle at the suggestion that Ukraine barter territory for peace with Russia.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.