“With” requires a direct connection to NATO
Gregory 15 Gregory, Circuit Judge, with Harris, Circuit Judge, and Hamilton, Senior Circuit Judge, delivering the Opinon of the United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit, in United States of America v. Bollinger, 798 F.3d 201, No. 14–4086, decided 8-19-2015, https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-4th-circuit/1710959.html /GoGreen!
The second textual limitation—the fact that commerce must be “with foreign Nations”—requires a nexus between the United States and a foreign country. See Goodno, supra, at 1202 (observing that dictionaries contemporary to the Constitutional Convention defined “with” as “noting the means” or “noting connection” (internal quotation marks omitted)). The use of the word “with” in the foreign clause, instead of the word “among” as used in the interstate clause, merely suggests the obvious: Congress cannot regulate commerce “among” foreign nations because other nations do not submit their sovereignty to our regulatory powers.