Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

That does NOT limit the means employed – includes physical protection, civilian stakeholder engagement AND offensive operations

Sherman 13 Commander Darren C. Sherman, United States Navy, Master of Strategic Studies candidate, United States Army War College, “U.S. Cybersecurity Defense Assessment,” MSS thesis, March 2013, https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/ADA589433.pdf /GoGreen!

In order to effectively apply national cybersecurity defense measures against these cyberspace attacks, the term cybersecurity defense must be clearly defined. For example, at each level of government – political, strategic, operational, and tactical, differing points of view exist regarding strategic level cybersecurity defense.5 These varying perspectives influence how cybersecurity defense is defined and how national cybersecurity strategy is interpreted and implemented. Moreover, the terms national cybersecurity and cybersecurity defense are used synonymously in U.S. policy discussions, which further complicates classifying cybersecurity defense. This is an important distinction because different definitions of cybersecurity have significant implications on the actions or operations of cybersecurity defense agencies and impacts the cybersecurity defense roles adopted by various levels of government during national policy and strategy formulation.

Analyses of twenty different cybersecurity strategies in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization’s (NATO) National Cyber Security Framework Manual6 reveal that diverging variations of cybersecurity defense definitions are common. This manual advocates that government organizations differentiate their cybersecurity defenses activities based upon national cybersecurity perspective, unique network capabilities, and or Federal agency partnerships.7 For example, several cybersecurity strategies contained in this manual8 propose the integration of multi-dimensional cyber security efforts in which government, society, and influential stakeholders work together in cooperation to provide adequate levels of cybersecurity defense.9 Exacerbating this situation, many of the cybersecurity defense processes developed to support cybersecurity definitions hinder generic government collaboration internally. However, to what end is not so clearly identified and different cybersecurity strategies are based uniquely upon different cybersecurity definitions. Within the complex conceptual framework of cybersecurity defense, the United States has established the following three definitions used interchangeably throughout the cybersecurity defense strategy formulation process.

One cybersecurity defense paradigm embraced by the U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) is characterized as organizational actions required to ensure “security of information in all its forms – electronic and physical, and the security of the systems and networks where information is stored, accessed, processed, and transmitted, including precautions taken to guard against crime, attack, sabotage, espionage, accidents and failures.”10 This definition is especially useful for DoD operations, as it does not limit the departments’ actions in mitigating potential cyber threats. Another cybersecurity defense classification is utilized by the U.S. military services and integrates a Joint Operations point of view. This definition advocates the use of Computer Network Defense (CND) actions to include “protecting, monitoring, analyzing, detecting, and responding to unauthorized activity within Department of Defense (DoD) information systems and computer networks.”11 Again the premise behind this classification is freedom to maneuver regarding cybersecurity defensive actions. Lastly, U.S. Cyber Command (USCYBERCOM) uses a strictly operational taxonomy to describe cybersecurity defensive operations – “direct and synchronized actions to detect, analyze, counter and mitigate cyber threats and vulnerabilities; to out maneuver adversaries taking or about to take offensive actions; and to otherwise protect critical missions that enable US freedom of action in cyberspace.”12 While all of the actions contained in these definitions are fundamental to the successful defense of critical national and federal network systems, the USCYBERCOM explanation is the most directive in implying a position of offensive action.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.