Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Resolved requires certainty

Dafoe 12 --- Allan Dafoe A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley, “Resolve, Reputation, and War: Cultures of Honor and Leaders’ Time-in-Oce”, Spring 2012, http://digitalassets.lib.berkeley.edu/etd/ucb/text/Dafoe_berkeley_0028E_12255.pdf (BJN)

Furthermore, based on my reading of historical crises, I believe that concern for reputation is a substantively critical determinant of resolve, and perhaps the most interesting component, analytically and for policy. To see this, it is helpful to look at how the term resolve, and synonyms, are actually used. The Oxford English Dictionary5 defines resolve as follows (I only list the more common usages): 1.a. The fact of having resolved upon a course of action, stance, etc.; a firm intention. Also in pl. in same sense (now somewhat arch.). 1.b. An act of resolving to do something; a resolution. 2. Firmness or steadfastness of purpose; determination; an instance of this... And OED defines “resolved” as (I only list usages related to human behavior): 1.a. Of the mind, etc.: freed from doubt or uncertainty; settled. Obs. 1.b. Of a person: convinced, satisfied, or certain of something. Obs. 1.c. Of doctrine: adopted or accepted after careful deliberation. Obs. 2.a. Of a person: that has resolved to do something; having fixed intention; determined, decided. 2.b. Of an action, state of mind, etc.: fully determined upon, deliberate. 2.c. Of a person: staunch, dedicated; committed, confirmed; that is thoroughly committed to the specified or implied course of action, practice, religious belief, doctrine, etc. 3. Of a person, the mind, etc.: characterized by determination or firmness of purpose; resolute. 4. That has been decided or resolved on or upon. As is clear from these definitions, the term resolve is often understood as referring to the result of a process of deliberation, decision, and commitment. One resolves to do something. In this sense, resolve is not simply a byproduct of a weighing of the pros and cons of escalating, but is instead a decision that one makes and then commits to. When Pericles sought to persuade the Athenians to reject the Spartan ultimatum, he argued that the decision over whether to make even a trivial concession under coercion was a “test of your resolution” (The Peloponnesian War , p. 1.140.5; under Warner translation, “proof of your determination”). It was common knowledge that the final Spartan demand—rescinding of a minor piece of economic statecraft known as the Megarian Decree—was extremely modest and of little material consequence to the Athenians. Pericles and other Athenians were not concerned that they would get a reputation for having a particular set of interests, such as not caring about the Megarian Decree. It is, after all, largely futile for a democracy, such as Classical Athens, to try to build a reputation for having certain interests since the preferences of various groups are readily observed through their democratic process of public deliberation. As Pericles pointed out, what was at stake was Athens’ reputation for committing to its position, which in this case was the principle that Athens and Sparta should treat each other as equals and overcome disputes through arbitration. A reputation for resolve is not a reputation for wanting to fight over many issues, but a reputation for being willing to fight for those issues that one commits to.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.