“Chasing data” problems are solved in implementation – our link outweighs
Van Eerden 20 Captain James R. R. Van Eerden, deputy director, chief operations officer, and Marine detachment officer-in-charge, National Security Agency, graduate of the Expeditionary Warfare School, Marine Corps University, “Seeking Alpha in the Security Cooperation Enterprise: A New Approach to Assessments and Evaluations,” Journal of Advanced Military Studies, 11(1), Spring 2020, DOI 10.21140/mcuj.2020110105, pp.113-126 /GoGreen!
Despite the many benefits of adopting the methodology, there are also some drawbacks. One potential problem with the methodology is that it can create a culture of chasing the data, where security cooperation teams and partner forces are motivated by test performance at the expense of genuine teaching and learning. Although this challenge is worth consideration, it is not enough to overcome the need for assessments. When properly trained, security cooperation instructors recognize that assessments are only one aspect of effective education. A healthy educational culture is established by team leadership, and trainers must be willing to adjust the format and frequency of the assessments to prevent unhealthy obsession about data. One method for reducing the focus on assessments during partner force engagements is to ensure that the assessment results are anonymous. Reflecting on his time as a security cooperation team leader in Gabon and Ghana in 2017, First Lieutenant Brendan Gallahue summarized his approach to testing: “At the end of the initial assessment, we debriefed the group on how they performed and explained the average score for the collective unit, without posting each individual’s scores.”20 Security cooperation teams can mitigate an unhealthy assessment culture by promoting groupwide improvement and retaining close control of assessment results.