Short-term bias makes the most useful AM&E particularly likely to get deprioritized in the face of plan’s fiat of an urgent new priority
Dyekman 7 Gregory J. Dyekman, Colonel, U.S. Army, Chief of Effects Assessment and Targeting in the Strategic Operations Directorate, MultiNational Force Iraq, MSS Army War College, MS Management, Troy State University, “Security Cooperation: A Key to the Challenges of the 21st Century,” Strategic Studies Institute, November 2007, https://publications.armywarcollege.edu/pubs/1916.pdf /GoGreen!
Resource challenges to security cooperation derive from fiscal constraints, Operational Tempo (OPTEMPO), Global Force Posturing, and outdated authorities. From a fiscal standpoint, the strategic environment will make the task of addressing our security challenges problematic for the foreseeable future. DoD’s 2007 budget is projected to be 3.9 percent of gross domestic product (GDP). As a percentage of GDP, DoD outlays are historically low and have not kept pace with the growth of GDP over the last 40 years.31 However, the rising costs of mandatory government entitlement spending associated with Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security are projected to account for 11 percent of the U.S. GDP by 2016 and will exert pressures on a budget that economic growth alone is unlikely to alleviate.32 Entitlement obligations will likely result in political pressure to further reduce defense discretionary spending in order to forestall greater budget deficits. Despite the constrained fiscal environment, DoD outlays must continue to grow to meet our global engagement requirements. This should be a continuous strategic communication message implemented by DoD senior leadership to Congress and the American people to counter a growing view that the federal government already spends too much on national defense.33
Despite having the authority to plan and conduct security cooperation within their area of responsibility (AOR), GCCs currently lack sufficient dedicated resources to support their security cooperation strategy. In addition, existing resources are limited by multiple and conflicting policy and legislation. Up to 30 sources of funding regulated by various authorities and guidelines are required to implement GCC security cooperation strategies.34 Security Assistance programs like international military education and training (IMET), foreign military financing (FMF), and financial management service (FMS) are State Department funded, and COCOMs have limited ability through the interagency process to influence where and how this money is spent.35 Other sources like Warsaw Initiative Funding (WIF) and Cooperative Threat Reduction (CTR) funding support military exercises and capacity building efforts but continue to come under increased program management scrutiny. In the past, security cooperation funding by Service Components has contributed significantly to COCOM plan execution. However, Service Chiefs face growing fiscal obligations. As an example, the Army delayed submitting its 2008-13 Program Objective Memorandum in an effort to avoid a QDR strategy and resource mismatch.36 A mismatch still exists, and the Army faces a growing problem in funding current equipment wartime reset requirements and its modernization efforts. In recent congressional testimony, the Army Chief of Staff outlined the Army equipment reset bill at $17.01 billion for FY 2007, with expected requirements beyond 2007 to be $12 to $13 billion per year though the conflict and a minimum of 2 to 3 years beyond.37 Additionally, the Army will need nearly $200 billion for the Future Combat System and its associated spin-off technologies to meet modernization requirements.38 These fiscal realities suggest Service components will have fewer resources to dedicate to security cooperation, as Service Chiefs, who already have less interest in engagement programs, struggle to meet their Title 10 responsibilities to train, organize, and equip their forces.39 To overcome these hurdles, funding streams must be consolidated and reforms initiated that provide GCCs more influence in the allocation of funding resources for security cooperation.
COCOMs will also likely face continued challenges in finding sufficient resources in the form of military personnel to conduct security cooperation programs. The Joint Strategic Capabilities Plan (JSCP) does not apportion forces specifically for security cooperation, and they must come from forces assigned to a COCOM’s AOR or that temporarily deploy for engagement activities.40 For the foreseeable future, the deployment requirements to support the GWOT will continue to leave few opportunities for active and reserve component units to participate in coalition and multinational exercises. In struggling to meet its surge requirements in Iraq and Afghanistan, the U.S. military is falling short in its ability to resource the steady-state deterrence and partner enabling missions called for in the QDR strategy.41 To address this shortcoming, President George W. Bush’s 2008 budget contains proposed funding for an additional end-strength increase of 92,000 troops for the Army and Marine Corps by 2013.42 This increase is not only necessary now, but also is required post-Iraq/Afghanistan. The Army must be forthright and convincing with the nation’s civilian defense leadership about the future force structure required to meet the myriad of “Boots on the Ground” tasks necessitated by an uncertain and complex environment.43
In the long term, the Realigned Global Force Posture aimed at creating a CONUS based expeditionary force could have negative consequences for future shaping activities. The Army has typically provided over 60 percent of the support to the GCC engagement efforts through its forward stationed forces.44 In Europe alone, Army restationing will reduce the forward presence in Europe to only two permanent Brigade Combat Teams. Potential GWOT commitments aside, this reduction in forward based forces will either reduce USEUCOM’s military exercise and training programs or significantly increase transportation costs for CONUS based force participation. Alleviating some of these issues will be the decision to rotate forces to Bulgaria and Romania. General John Craddock, the new Supreme Allied Commander Europe (SACEUR), views this as an opportunity to “focus on mil-to-mil activities that continue to build the military capacities of new NATO Alliance and perspective Alliance countries along with strategic partners in Eastern Europe and Eurasia.”45 However, to truly allow GCCs the predictable manning resources, TSCPs must be integrated into the Global Force Management construct. The Army Force Generation (ARFORGEN) model provides a great opportunity to make forces available for GCC security cooperation requirements.
Resource challenges are also found in the numerous policy, regulatory, and legislative constraints governing the execution of programs. In testimony before the House Armed Services Committee, SACEUR General James L. Jones said:
Although the threats we face have changed dramatically, resources available for security cooperation, one of our key enablers in dealing with present day challenges, are still used as they have been since the Cold War. They are applied for deliberate, long-lead-time system built to address a single, enduring and predictable enemy.46
An example of outdated resourcing can be found in the authorities enabling the military to train and equip partner nations. The GTEP, while eventually successful, required funding from seven different agencies and allied contributions delaying the program start by seven months.47 Most State Department funded security assistance programs like FMS require multiple years to be put in place. To overcome this, the Bush administration sought and received limited authority to train or equip other countries’ militaries to respond to critical needs and meet emergent threats and opportunities. Under a 2-year pilot program, Section 1206 of the National Defense Authorization Act for 2006 provided $200 million in authority for GCCs to build the capability of military forces of a foreign country to conduct counterterrorist operations or participate in or support stability operations.48 While a vast improvement, the amendment still lacks elements the DoD requested, and others desired. Key among these is the limitation on training only national military forces vice border security and other security forces engaged in counterterrorism and stability operations.49 In its Building Global Partnerships Act of 2007, DoD submitted legislation for congressional consideration to expand the type of forces that may be trained and increase the funding ceiling to $750 million while making the 1206 authority permanent.50 The Act also seeks legislative provisions to streamline the authorities to increase our partners’ capacities through logistical and material support. It contains requests for permanent authorities to loan significant military equipment to coalition partners participating in combined operations and to allow GCCs to make grants of nonlethal excess defense articles.51 These legislative proposals to increase authorities are critical to increasing our partners’ effectiveness and must be enacted, streamlined, and fully funded.
Another example of legislative constraints exists with the DoD Regional Centers. Legislatively, the centers are now able to fund only military and civilian defense officials. Expanding the participant pool would strengthen their ability to educate and network with those necessary to counter ideological support for terrorism. In Middle East societies, where religion is so deeply integrated, Imams with greater understanding of democratic principles and common security challenges could be influential with Muslim populations, thereby countering extremism. Strategic communications could be further enhanced if influential moderates with access to al-Jazzera were educated at the centers. Lacking authority to waive costs for a broader pool of participants, Regional Centers are unable to reach the influential audiences most critical to U.S. interests. In the uncertain and rapidly changing security environment we now face, we must not continue to embrace outdated models and antiquated mindsets in dealing with allies and partners. The flexibility offered by initiatives like partner capability and capacity building legislation in the Building Global Partnerships Act is a necessary start. To truly be effective, however, the United States must completely reexamine the Foreign Assistance Act and undertake broad reform of the ways in which we provide security assistance.
Another growing challenge to security cooperation lies in the necessity to properly assess and evaluate program effectiveness. In the domestic strategic environment of scarce and competing defense resources, it will be critical for COCOMs to evaluate their security cooperation programs to establish priorities, defend funding, and apply their resources where most needed. To date, the submission of engagement plans has simply served as a venue to capture and inform the Joint Staff of what the COCOMs are doing but fail to demonstrate their effectiveness.52 The 2005 Security Cooperation Guidance outlining the requirement to conduct an annual assessment of security cooperation activities in their AORs is a beginning. No assessment guidance has been published by DoD, however.
Historically, the subjective nature of security cooperation has made it very difficult to measure. Assessment has consisted mainly of capturing and reporting outputs, including details such as the number of exercises, students trained, and port calls have served as the measure of program success. Assessment templates should require addressing measures of performance, or how well a plan was executed and also how well programs are aligned with priorities for creating and building partnerships outlined in the Security Cooperation Guidance. To truly transform security cooperation effectiveness, however, one must address the difficult task of measuring effectiveness. Assessment plans should evaluate programs against broader cooperation efforts.53 COCOMs must begin to measure in terms of strategic outcomes, measuring the effectiveness of how well their plans build partners and capacity. The Building Partnership Capacity (BPC) Roadmap, signed in May 2006 by Deputy Defense Secretary Gordon England to provide a plan of action for implementing partnership capacity related QDR decisions, may prove constructive if it improves DoD’s ability to assess security cooperation investments.54
While properly measuring effectiveness is vitally important to prioritizing resources, caution must be taken to avoid a short-term focus. The emerging security environment may lead to a significant resource struggle to achieve a proper balance between short- and long-term programs with respect to measuring the effectiveness of attaining security cooperation objectives. A steady shift to more immediate, tangible, and measurable outcomes from theater security programs is likely. However, a business mindset towards assessments should not force policy practices to favor short term, metric oriented programs that have quick and measurable tactical effects. The difficulty of measuring security cooperation success creates problems when evaluating progress over time. Many long-term benefits in engagement programs that build partner will through trust and mutual understanding exceed the scope of any single program and progress more often comes from multiple programs conducted over many years.55 Ongoing multifaceted cooperation in the GWOT is an example where long-term U.S. military cooperation efforts have achieved valuable outcomes. In congressional testimony, USEUCOM Commander General Jones said:
Since September 11, 2001, nearly every nation in the USECUOM AOR has offered or provided intelligence, basing access, and over-flight rights, forces, and equipment as well as other forms of key support in our efforts to combat terrorism. The degree of support we have received is directly related to the effort and attention we have given to the security cooperation program that was in place well in advance of the current conflict.56
In the security environment of uncertainty the United States faces, long-term efforts to build and maintain a foundational base of security partners through exercises, military education, and exchanges are wise investments to hedge against future security challenges. Assessment constructs must capture both short- and long-term returns.