Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Counterplan
Opening Word document…

CP’s key---it builds momentum for the use of the OSCE as a forum for East-West dispute resolution, which builds progressive momentum for sustainable ties.

Matthew Levinger 18, George Washington University, “Forging Consensus for Atrocity Prevention: Assessing the Record of the OSCE,” Genocide Studies and Prevention: An International Journal: Vol. 11: Iss. 3: 60-74, http://doi.org/10.5038/1911-9933.11.3.1505

In recent years, however, some observers have questioned the effectiveness of the OSCE’s work, remarking on the “growing futility”9 of the OSCE as the EU has expanded its political and security-related missions. During the Cold War, a clear demarcation existed between the structure and function of the European Economic Community (EEC) and that of the CSCE: the EEC was a regional organization focusing on the economic integration of Western Europe, whereas the CSCE was an informal dialogue process promoting cooperative security measures between NATO and the Warsaw Pact. In 1993, the EEC was subsumed under the EU, which had a more comprehensive mission including a Common Foreign and Security Policy. Over the past quarter-century, a “functional convergence” has occurred between the EU and OSCE. Not only has the EU expanded eastward into the former Warsaw Pact region, it has increasingly taken on political and security functions, such as election monitoring and security sector reform, that had previously been the province of the OSCE.10 The eastward expansion of NATO and the EU has also put the Russian Federation on the defensive. Russian leaders have argued that “instead of acting as a genuine transatlantic organization, the OSCE has evolved into an institution that seeks to act as a tool of Western influence, pushing forward an agenda of excessive intrusion and potential destabilization in Russia’s neighborhood.”11 As long ago as 2006, one expert asserted: “The OSCE is in crisis. . . . There can be no doubt but that the OSCE today, as compared to its heyday during the Cold War, is a far less visible landmark on the European institutional landscape than was formerly the case.”12

This essay will argue that the OSCE continues to play a unique and vital role in preventing and containing ethnic conflict in Europe and Central Asia, but that its greatest distinctive strength— the capacity to help foster shared political norms supporting “common and comprehensive security”—has eroded since the late 1990s. Part I of the essay will discuss the original operating concept of the CSCE and OSCE, which sought to constitute a cooperative transatlantic security community through the promulgation of shared norms. Part II will examine the erosion of the normative consensus between the Eastern and Western participating States of the OSCE since the late 1990s, focusing on some Eastern states’ distrust for the Western democracy promotion agenda. Finally, Part III will examine the prospects for a more robust role of the OSCE in protecting civilians from violent conflict and mass atrocities, given the increasing tensions among Eastern and Western OSCE participating States in recent years.

The OSCE Ideal: Community Building Through Norm Formation

Emanuel Adler has evocatively termed the OSCE an “imagined security community,” describing the logic of the organization’s founders as follows:

[T]he OSCE has adopted the view that you must first let the largest number of people from different states imagine that they are part of a community; only then, when all have formally and instrumentally accepted the institution’s shared normative structures and practices, do you socialize their elites and peoples by means of continual diplomatic interaction and a wide range of community-building practices.13

Adler’s description of the OSCE community-building enterprise points to the power of norms not only to constrain or regulate behavior but also to constitute new communal identities:

When assessing and measuring the influence of OSCE’s practices, we cannot simply look at this institution’s regulative tasks or short-range activities, because what matters most is the long-range effectiveness of its practices and activities as constitutive of community identity and bonds . . . [W]hat matters most is not the short-range success of the mission, seminar, or inspection, but the construction of a foundation for community practice and behavior.14

Although it might be tempting to dismiss the OSCE’s “seminar diplomacy” as an elaborate sleight of hand, conjuring the illusion of a transatlantic community that remains purely imaginary, this would ignore the real historical impact of the CSCE/OSCE enterprise. During the 1970s and 1980s, the Helsinki Process created a space for the articulation of human rights claims by dissident groups in the Warsaw Pact, which played a role in facilitating a peaceful end to the Cold War. Since the early 1990s, the HCNM and other OSCE institutions have sought to foster “an environment characterized by shared meanings, trust, increased cooperation, and a sense of common identity.”15 For all the frustrations and setbacks involved in this project, there have also been important successes.

Of the various component institutions of the OSCE, two are particularly relevant to the mission of atrocity prevention: the Conflict Prevention Center (CPC), along with the field operations that it supports, and the Office of the High Commissioner on National Minorities (HCNM). These will be the focus of analysis for this paper.

Created in 1990, the CPC “acts as an OSCE-wide early warning focal point, facilitates negotiation, mediation, and other conflict prevention and resolution efforts, and supports regional co-operation initiatives.”16 In its initial years, the CPC focused principally on reducing risks of interstate conflict among the OSCE participating States, for example by promoting Confidence and Security Building Measures such as exchange of military information.

Over the past two decades, the mandate of the CPC has expanded to include early warning, situation monitoring, mediation and dialogue facilitation, and support for OSCE field operations, among other roles. It supports mediation initiatives in Ukraine, Nagorno-Karabakh, Transdniestria, and Georgia.17 The OSCE also currently deploys sixteen field operations in South-Eastern Europe, Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus, and Central Asia, addressing issues including reconciliation and human rights protection in the Balkan states, conflict monitoring in Ukraine, and the monitoring and prevention of ethnic conflict in Kyrgyzstan.18

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.