Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Counterplan
Opening Word document…

Sparks terrorism and ethnic conflict---goes global

Simone Florio 12, Faculty of Political Science and Sociology at the University of Granada, “The Fragmentation of Geopolitical Space”, The International Relations and Security Network, 11-26, http://www.isn.ethz.ch/Digital-Library/Articles/Special-Feature/Detail/?lng=en&id=155328&tabid=1453404549&contextid774=155328&contextid775=155325

Editor’s Note: Today's special feature lays the foundations for our week-long look at how separatist and secessionist movements may be impacting upon regional and global security dynamics, both now and in the future. Indeed, as a counter to last week’s state-centric meditation on grand strategy, we present today excerpts from Simone Florio's "The Fragmentation of Geopolitical Space: What Secessionist Movements Mean to the Present-day State System." The article not only charts the growing clamor for political secession since the end of the Cold War, it also explores its deeper implications for international security. In doing so, it then sets the stage for a follow-on series of case studies on secessionist movements in Europe, China and the wider Middle East.

The last century witnessed an extraordinary multiplication of sovereign states. Epochal changes such as the dissolution of 20th century empires, the decolonization process, and the end of the Cold War determined the division of the world landscape into nearly two hundred separate polities. But the trend to geopolitical fragmentation still has momentum: partially recognized and de facto states constitute a big challenge for international order, while a conspicuous number of active secessionist projects continue to threaten the territorial integrity of many countries. This article reviews the complex questions that the trend to geopolitical fragmentation is posing to global society, reviewing a number of normative secession theories and evidencing in them a more hospitable approach to new state formation. Given the current regime of sovereign states, framing a global approach to the problems posed by separatist groups seems almost inconceivable; for the time being, it seems likely instead that the international community will continue accepting new states on a case-by-case basis, often in response to Great Power interests or non-negotiable nationalist projects, without advancing international law on state creation or global standards of statehood as a whole. This article provides support for the claim that adopting a global perspective and more functional attitudes towards geopolitical restructuring are paramount for effectively dealing with violence deriving from the clash of nationalist separatist drives and state-centric conservatism.

The Fragmentation of Geopolitical Space: What Secessionist Movements Mean to the Present-Day State System

Throughout the last century, the society of sovereign nations has grown steadily, giving rise – for distinct reasons and under different modalities – to our present-day international structure comprised of almost 200 sovereign states, the primary geopolitical units of the world system. Epochal changes in the international order, such as the disintegration of European empires in the early 20th century, the decolonization process, and lastly the end of the Cold War, brought about an extraordinary proliferation of independent states: during the past twenty years, full independence was accorded – through United Nations membership – to twenty-five former sub-state entities. Although such major geopolitical reconfiguration undoubtedly followed events of an exceptional nature, these events have severely destabilized the idea (dominant in the second half of last century) that international borders should not – or could not – be modified to create new states. As is widely acknowledged, this is nowadays achieved mainly by way of secession, intended as the process by which a political community seeks to detach part of an existing state in order to establish a separate sovereign entity.

The tendency to fragmentation becomes relevant most notably: a) when effective control is established on part of a sovereign state on behalf of a secessionist community, with the aim of fostering international recognition of the new polity; and b) when separatist politics – with differing degrees of legitimacy and success – are pursued within the territory of a sovereign state in order to achieve political goals, including the chance of seceding from the state. (1) To the first category belong those independent territorial entities – so-called de facto states (2) — which rely on the ‘principle of effectiveness’ to support their claim to sovereign statehood. (3) Especially when patronized (more or less officially) by external actors – and especially by Great Powers (4) –de facto states pose a dramatic challenge to the international system, since they operate in a grey area of international relations and international law. To the second category belong a great variety of territorially organized sub-state entities (federal/confederal entities, autonomous regions, etc.) and non-state actors (stateless nations, indigenous peoples, national and ethnic minorities) which – in different capacities and on various grounds – actively seek to increase their sovereign powers to possibly attain title over the territory they occupy, most commonly by appealing to the right of self-determination.

While it seems inappropriate to establish a causal relation between secessionism/separatism and armed conflict or the outbreak of ethnic violence, (5) as of 2009 secessionism and separatism considered together constitute the second most frequent source of conflict. (6) In plenty of cases secessionism is connected to practices of both terror and terrorism, respectively, on behalf of states –whose institutions tend to dispose of disproportionate military means to crush insurgents – and non-state groups –whose unscrupulous leaders may resort to terrorism as an opportunistic strategy to escalate and internationalize conflicts. (7) Furthermore, since the creation and maintenance of states is always cemented through specific nation-building policies, secessionist/separatist conflicts often arise along dangerous ethno-nationalist fault lines and perpetuate ethno-political confrontation. Finally, the salience of the trend to fragmentation is confirmed not merely by the progressive enlargement of the society of states, but rather by the fact that – in spite of such enlargement – the number of secessionist movements has at the same time remained practically constant. (8) These indications suggest that separatism – and secessionist politics in particular – is one of the most serious challenges to both state institutions and the international order as a whole: in fact, secessionist projects are pursued worldwide, under both democratic and non-democratic regimes, by both violent and non-violent means.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.