Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Counterplan
Opening Word document…

NATO credibility hurts the Global South and wrecks chances for success

Rogers 5/21/22 (Paul Rogers is Emeritus Professor of Peace Studies in the Department of Peace Studies and International Relations at Bradford University, and an Honorary Fellow at the Joint Service Command and Staff College. He is openDemocracy’s international security correspondent, The Ukraine war has given NATO renewed credibility. That’s a problem, https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/ukraine-russia-war-nato-putin-finland-sweden-problem-strengthened/ )//MargaretE

It is assumed that good times will continue to roll for the military-industrial complexes of Europe, as with the latest kit, even if the abject failure of the Russia armed forces hardly suggests that bigger budgets are needed. Not everything fits neatly into place, though, and two very troubling issues lie ahead. The first is that in the past two decades, NATO has been anything but a success. In Afghanistan, it was in charge of the from 2003 to 2014 and then the smaller, non-combat force, ‘Resolute Support Mission’, from 2015 through to the end of the disastrous war last year. In 2011, Libya was another NATO failure, where the bloc was said to be involved in a humanitarian intervention but ended up overseeing regime change, leaving a failed state in its wake. Beyond these, though, is the much bigger issue: NATO is well-nigh irrelevant when it comes to the main global security challenges, climate breakdown and the widening socioeconomic divide. Africans support the Ukrainian people, but centuries of experience also make us wary of ‘solutions’ by our former colonisers. We are currently seeing an impact of the . Records are being broken daily but the remarkable thing that sets this apart from other serious heatwaves is that it is happening than would be expected. We are also seeing warnings of , stemming in part from climate factors but also fuelled by market impacts of the Ukraine war. As in the world food crisis of the 1970s, though, it is also down to socioeconomic factors. Now, as then, there are enough grain reserves to go around, but hundreds of millions of people simply cannot afford to pay the soaring prices. Both the heatwave and the food crisis are early signs of what is to come if economic reform and radical decarbonisation are not implemented, and they mean that we are heading for a deeply unstable and insecure world. If the Ukraine war does end soon, NATO will emerge as an increasingly strong and confident alliance, yet it will be close to irrelevant when it comes to the real global challenges. More than that, given its performance in Afghanistan and Libya, NATO will be seen increasingly as a negative influence across the Global South, an alliance dominated by white Western states committed to protecting their own security. commented on the attitude to the Ukraine war in lower-income countries, with tepid support for the West mixed with a ‘plague on both your houses’ mood. If NATO is to be relevant in a fractured world, it will have to evolve very quickly into a different kind of alliance. This must be part of a global transformation of understanding about security that is becoming more and more urgent. It is a lot to hope for, but if NATO doesn’t change, it won’t just be irrelevant, it will be an increasing part of the problem.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.