Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Counterplan
Opening Word document…

The BRI is key to Chinese geoeconomics influence and hegemony

Beeson and Crawford 2/10 – Mark Beeson is Professor of International Politics at the University of Western Australia in Perth. Corey Crawford is a professor at the University of Western Australia. (“Putting the BRI in Perspective: History, Hegemony and Geoeconomics,” Springer. February 10th, 2022. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s41111-022-00210-y) CTF

The ‘rise of China’ or—more accurately—China’s re-emergence as the most important actor in what we now think of as East Asia is one of the most important developments in world history. This may strike some readers as an extravagant claim, but it is not without foundation. Not only is the economy of the People’s Republic of China (PRC) on track to overtake the United States’ (US) as the world’s largest economy in the near future (Cheng and Lee 2021), but it is the first credible candidate to become a non-Western hegemonic power. The fact that it is from Asia is noteworthy enough; the idea that it is a ‘communist’ power that subscribes to a very different idea about the best ways of organising social, political, economic, and strategic activities is even more remarkable. At the very least, the PRC’s ascension provides a striking illustration of the possibility that very different routes to global power are conceivable. The key questions in this context are not just whether ‘Chinese hegemony’ is possible, but how it might differ from the more familiar American variety that has dominated the international system and the world views of nearly everyone alive today.

To try and answer these questions, we focus on China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). If successfully realised, the BRI will be the most ambitious and expansive developmental project the world has ever seen. While there has been an unsurprising flurry of interest inside and outside China about the development of the BRI (Beeson 2020a, b; Clarke 2017; Winter 2019), there have been few attempts to place the BRI in comparative perspective, or to consider it as an expression of possible hegemonic influence. Given that the BRI is not unprecedented, this is surprising. After all, in the aftermath of the Second World War, the US developed what was then an equally unprecedented and ambitious initiative designed to simultaneously facilitate the (re)development of some of the world’s key economies and reinforce its own position as the leader of the non-communist world (Pollard 1985).

Both the American Marshall Plan and China’s BRI are, therefore, important expressions of what has been described as ‘geoeconomic’ influence and power (Blackwill and Harris 2016; Luttwak 1990). In what follows, we compare the two projects to try and gauge the prospects for the BRI and some of its associated institutions. Significantly, the BRI lacks the same sort of compelling geopolitical imperatives and narrative that the emerging Cold War provided for the US and its allies (Gaddis 1982). At this point, at least, the Chinese project also lacks the comprehensive institutional architecture that facilitated American ‘hegemonic’ influence. Consequently, we argue that it may prove more difficult for China to impose or develop the same sort of coherent vision and geopolitical goals that the Americans did, raising doubts about its long-term significance, despite its unparalleled ambitions (Beeson 2009).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.