Current mechanisms for trade fail
Donato 20 – Giulia Di Donato is a journalist at ISPI. (“China’s Approach to the Belt and Road Initiative and Europe’s Response,” ISPI. May 8th, 2020. https://www.ispionline.it/it/pubblicazione/chinas-approach-belt-and-road-initiative-and-europes-response-25980) CTF
Today, the European Union, as the final destination of the BRI and a key targeted export market for Chinese products, has critical strategic importance for the success of this ambitious Chinese project. Although the ports of Piraeus in Greece and Venice in Italy have been indicated in the official maps as the main end points of the BRI, it still remains unclear whether Chinese interests could be further expanded into other routes and whether other terminals will be targeted as entry points in the EU and the Mediterranean[15].
In 2015, Hungary was the first European country to sign a MoU with China under the BRI and, by 2019, another 22 European countries had signed BRI co-operation agreements, with the latest being Luxembourg and Italy[16]. However, leaders of countries like France and Germany, which refused to officially participate in the BRI, adopted a more cautious approach and expressed their concerns about the Chinese-sponsored project. In particular, they advocated for more balanced rules to avoid a “one-way trade road” and the increase of China’s influence in the Balkans[17].
In 2013, the same year the BRI was launched, the EU and China adopted the “EU-China 2020 Strategic Agenda for Cooperation”, calling for increased cooperation to promote peace, prosperity, sustainable development and people-to-people exchanges[18]. Nonetheless, in 2015 the EU launched the “EU-China Connectivity Platform”, the European Commission’s first significant response to the BRI (Kuo 2019). Established by the European Commission and the National Development and Reform Commission of China, this bilateral platform was aimed at improving transparency, reciprocity in market access and a level playing field for businesses in the area of transport infrastructure, as well as enhancing synergies between the EU’s connectivity projects, including the Trans-European Transport Network (TEN-T)[19] and China’s Belt and Road Initiative[20]. The main tangible result of this platform relates to the organization of annual high-level meetings bringing together chairpersons and expert groups from both sides to foster their collaboration on transport infrastructure projects. However, although the connectivity platform continues to function, it does not appear to have resulted in any major practical instances of European engagement with or involvement in the BRI (Kuo 2019).