Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Counterplan
Opening Word document…

eu solvency – generic EU security cooperation is possible

Menon 22 – Rajan Menon is the director of grand strategy at Defense Priorities. (“A NEW AND BETTER SECURITY ORDER FOR EUROPE,” Defense Priorities. February 15th, 2022. https://www.defensepriorities.org/explainers/a-new-and-better-security-order-for-europe) CTF

UPDATE OUR COLD WAR STRATEGY FOR TODAY’S GEOSTRATEGIC REALITIES

The premises and practices that underpin current U.S. strategy toward Europe amount to a tweaking of those that prevailed during the Cold War, never mind that the conditions in Europe are now wholly different. Europe has long since become an economic and technological powerhouse, even a rival of the United States in global markets. No country with military power comparable to the Soviet Union now threatens the European balance of power (Ukraine is not critical to that balance). The European Union, most of whose members also belong to NATO, has a GDP that is more than nine times larger than Russia’s: €13 trillion versus €1.4 trillion. Europe is also technologically far superior to Russia.10 Clearly, then, Europeans have the material wherewithal to develop the capacity to deter Russia.

PERILS OF PRIMACY: WEALTHY ALLIES CAN OUTSOURCE NATIONAL DEFENSE

Now is the time for the United States to champion Europe’s strategic autonomy. Not only has it failed to do so, but it has also steadfastly opposed the idea. Instead, it complains intermittently about the inequitable defense burden within NATO while allowing it to persist.11 Rather than harping on burden sharing, the United States should move toward “burden shifting” that begins with reductions in American forces and eventually leads to European self-sufficiency in defense and the elimination of a permanent U.S. military presence. That change need not involve the jettisoning of NATO.

Because the United States has not demanded more of its European NATO allies, their progress toward meeting the benchmarks adopted at the 2014 Wales Summit for national defense spending (2 percent of GDP) and military procurement (20 percent of the military budget) has, unsurprisingly, been spotty at best, something NATO’s most recent figures make clear.12 Moreover, Germany, Europe’s wealthiest state, is among the biggest laggards. Not only has Germany still not met the Wales targets, but the Bundeswehr is also inadequately funded, understaffed, and lacks all manner of equipment and spare parts.13 Had the Wales benchmarks been met, European defense spending would have increased by billions of dollars.

The curious upshot has been that an increasing preoccupation with the Russian threat coexists with Europeans’ failure to take the steps needed to address it.

CODEPENDENCY AND THWARTING “STRATEGIC AUTONOMY”

Europeans have become accustomed to a regional security order that has persisted for over seven decades and features a permanent U.S. military presence and security guarantee.14 If one is a European, what’s not to like?

This arrangement goes beyond European dependency on the United States. It resembles what psychologists call codependency, with a provider and a recipient, each locked into their roles and unable to construct an alternative. The dynamic persists because American leaders do not want a change in the status quo. One of the enduring legacies of post-World War II American primacy is the U.S. foreign and national security community—the executive and legislative branches of government, the media, academic specialists, and think tanks—remains convinced a stable world order cannot exist unless the United States maintains, and regularly displays, its preponderance, lest adversaries become challengers and dominoes start to fall. The habitual invocation of “credibility” owes to this mindset.15

A NEW, STRONGER SECURITY ORDER FOR EUROPE

BURDEN SHIFTING: EUROPEANS ARE WEALTHY AND CAN FIELD MODERN MILITARY POWER

Europe can defend itself and should do far more for its own defense than it does now.16 In addition to spending more on their own defense, European countries should develop an independent conception of security that progressively moves their continent toward autonomy. First, they should eradicate the problems that impair military effectiveness. A case in point: the shortage of the most basic equipment and essential parts for warships, warplanes, and submarines that plague the Bundeswehr, the army of Europe’s richest nation.17 Next, Europe should develop plans to harmonize defense production, especially by coordinating defense spending and replacing duplicative weapons production with a European-wide division of labor based on comparative advantage. This will not be easy because of the pressure leaders will inevitably face to keep production and jobs within their countries and to support national defense industries. Still, there is a difference between defense production based on national autarchy and a collective approach. The latter would exploit opportunities for various forms of collaboration, including coproducing armaments, divvying up different parts of the production process, and exploiting comparative advantages.

Whether and to what degree greater European strategic self-sufficiency is worked out in cooperation with the United Kingdom should be a matter for Europeans to decide. The same goes for whether strategic autonomy coexists with a reformed NATO or eventually replaces the alliance. The change should be implemented through close consultation between the United States and its allies and at a pace that does not create needless disruptions.

A NEW REGIONAL ORDER

Because of the economic and military distribution of power in Europe, Germany, the continent’s wealthiest country, and France, its sole full-service military power (the pair have a GDP 87 percent greater than Russia’s but combined spend more than $60 billion less on military expenditures based on Purchasing Power Parity, or PPP), will have to take responsibility for ushering Europe toward strategic autonomy.18 It is desirable for them to work in tandem because of the residual suspicions that linger about a Europe dominated by Germany. Under French President Emmanuel Macron at least, the French government has forcefully advocated for European strategic autonomy (most recently during the 2021–2022 Ukraine-Russia crisis), arguing Europe should have an independent voice and collective vision on continental security.19

As part of a new strategy toward Europe, the United States should help create a new regional order—one that integrates, rather than estranges, Russia. Alienating Russia, as it has been for most of the post-Cold War decades, has resulted in steadily increasing crises in eastern Europe.

The expansion of NATO—which has grown from 16 members at its Cold War highpoint to 30 in 2022—is but one part of the problem between Russia and the West, but it is a big one. Influential Americans nevertheless insist Russia’s concerns about the advance of a Cold War alliance toward its borders are contrived and unrelated to security. They regard the Russian president’s objections as a ruse to mask his (“real”) fear, namely that democracy could spread to adjacent countries and eventually threaten Russia’s authoritarian political order.20 While this may be true in part, a sound grand strategy must include an awareness that other countries may not share American perceptions and indeed may reject them wholesale.21

What the United States sees as benign (NATO expansion or European missile defense) Russia regards as threatening. A sound strategy also requires the willingness and capacity to understand how other countries perceive one’s actions and the humility to resist the urge to believe that you know what other countries’ actual interests and fears are. None of this means conceding what rivals want, let alone appeasement; it does mean a willingness to understand the world as they see it so that pathways can be found to advance U.S. interests and avoid crises and war through reasonable compromise.22 As former Secretary of State James A. Baker put it, “I would have to say that if there was one key to whatever success I’ve enjoyed in negotiating…it has been an ability to crawl into the other guy’s shoes. If you understand your opponent, you have a better chance of reaching a successful conclusion. That means paying attention to how they view issues and appreciating the political constraints they face.”23

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.