Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Affirmative
Opening Word document…

NATO is key. It occupies a unique role to credibly spearhead norm setting in emerging tech.

Ehlert 21 --- PhD. Head of Strategy and Policy in the Office of the Chief Scientist at NATO headquarters.

Ulf, 12-16-2021, "NATO Review," NATO Review, https://www.nato.int/docu/review/articles/2021/12/16/why-our-values-should-drive-our-technology-choices/index.html

It would be short-sighted to assume that Western countries could globally enforce emerging technologies’ compliance with Western values. Instead, differences in values may well result in divergent technological competences that can, in turn, affect the global distribution of power.

Setting norms – a role for NATO?

Emerging and Disruptive Technologies (EDTs) came into NATO’s political focus in 2019, when NATO leaders adopted an implementation roadmap for seven such technologies. Regardless of their tremendous promise, we must realise that these technologies are not yet mature, not yet “fully out there”. Therefore, considerable uncertainty remains to which extent these fledgling technologies and their foreseeable applications are appropriately contained within established legal, ethical, and moral norms. These questions are not limited to military applications, nor do they stop at national borders: rather, they cut across many government departments and business sectors, and they affect humanity in its entirety.

In this complex, fast moving, high-stake setting, we must view technology and values as intertwined. While our values should guide our use of technology, we must recognise that our technology choices will, whether intended or not, reflect the values we adhere to.

As inaction is not an option, we must take active measures to establish norms for the future use of technologies; norms that are deeply rooted in our values; technologies that are currently emerging and have recognised disruption potential (such as AI, biotechnology, and quantum technology). How could we realistically master this novel challenge? The following three proposals could pave the way.

We must effectively cope with the uncertainties of technology evolution. Hence, I suggest evolutionary policy-making, building on current knowledge, but flexible enough so that today’s decisions can be adjusted or corrected in the future.

We must strive to limit potential harm without unduly constraining the benefits a technology can bring. Therefore, our policies should set limits for the application of technologies (such as genetically optimised super-soldiers) rather than banning entire technology areas (in this case, biotechnology).

We need to understand when policy changes are necessary and what those changes should be. Reflecting the diversity of interests, we need to institutionalise a broad stakeholder engagement that reaches out to all parties affected by a technology and influencing its evolution.

Within this broadly applicable framing, NATO’s role is specific. As the international organisation committed to defence and security in the North Atlantic area, it convenes considerable political, military, economic, and technological power. Building in particular on its political and intellectual capital, the Alliance can credibly spearhead norm setting for technology applications in defence to comply with Western values.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.