Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Affirmative
Opening Word document…

The expansion of even “friendly AI” builds a bridge to a post-human hellscape, where geopolitics is structured around techno-dystopic racialized violence

Grove 20 – Associate Professor of Political Science and Director of the Hawai’i Research Center for Future Studies at the University of Hawai’I at Mānoa, PhD in International Relations at Johns Hopkins University [Jairus, “From geopolitics to geotechnics: global futures in the shadow of automation, cunning machines, and human speciation,” International Relations 2020, Vol. 34(3) 432 –455, DKP]

In Cavell’s account the general economy of violence that characterized the sadism of slavery could return again but differently. Rather than a great chain of being or the superiority or some races over others, the very concept of violence as a category distinct from force or change could be lost. Although extreme, can we not already see this transformation underway in the extreme forms of instrumentality that characterize decisions regarding collateral damage, counter-value targeting, or economized discourse on immigration and refugees?56

More than a transformation of moral economies, the automation of humans and the augmentation of humans, represents the possibility of making physical and habitual what is now normative and discursive. Resembling Cavell, David Roden proposes what he calls the disconnection thesis, in which Cavell’s nightmare scenario unfolds only among some humans for whom the sentimentality of bodies, reproduction, and human connection impede further evolution of the species.57 Whether it is those who dream of a singularity in which human consciousness becomes digital or one of the U.S. veterans who have had mood altering computer chips implanted into their brains, some humans will increasingly alter or altered their brain-body networks to alter their cognitive and perceptive capacities.58

During the summer of 2018 researchers at the University of Washington and Carnegie Mellon successfully networked three humans via EEGs and transcranial magnetic stimulation. The three individuals were able to collaborate to play a simple video game resembling Tetris.59 The participants were able to communicate and sense each others’ thoughts without the use of language or even being in the same room. Similar experiments have successfully sent text message from one side of the country to the other making at least a limited version of brain to brain communication a reality.

In the dark light of geopolitics one can imagine what today takes the form of geographic and class divides in connectivity and medicine taking the form of different classes and territories of consciousness and communication. Given the already gossamer fragility of international solidarity and trans-border empathy one can further imagine cyborg cultures quite literally tuning out of the world left behind. Roden’s disconnection thesis argues that as these new forms of networks and augmentation develop so too will cultures and moral awareness diverge.60 For those without the need or desire to use oral language accelerating the pace of technological change within new kinds of communities it is not difficult to follow Cavell to the precipice of his posthuman horror. While the biological racial fictions of colonialism, apartheid, and settler-colonialism still hold on in the face of overwhelming scientific evidence to the contrary how much more would real material differences in forms of life accelerate existing geopolitical violence?61 Even the beginnings of disconnection could intensify the already renewed fights between extractive industrial modernity and those indigenous communities fighting for their ancestral lands and ways of life. And what of the swelling numbers of multi-generationally unemployed masses who will lack the capital to upgrade? One can imagine class no longer being marked by linguistic markers or knowledge of wine but the physical ability to interface with white color working spaces. More and more companies have already begun microchipping their employees for security and tracking crossing the threshold of the skin in the process of making labor.62 The digital divide in labor of who can and cannot telecommute is already determining the patterns of employment and unemployment in the first 6 months of COVID-19 shutdowns. The speciation of interfaces and sensory capabilities could amplify the already growing trend.63

The point of Roden and Cavell’s thought experiments are to show that such a separation would be more than just a return to or intensification of racial or class divisions. Instead the very embodied character of moral appreciation, the shared languages and cultures, the perceptive capacities to experience beauty or tragedy could be altered to the point that the diffracted species of once human beings would live in a state more closely resembling that of Homo sapiens 100,000 years ago in which there were multiple species of upright anthropoids and none of them could live without the fear of predation by other non-human animals or each other. The medium of encounter fundamentally altered. However, in this speculative history of the future the divergence would not have been by happenstance but to lock in interests and geopolitical advantage. Difference by design.

This may all seem too far-fetched. How could humans lose their most basic capacity for socio-emotional intercourse? I want to argue that things need not change that dramatically to see the beginnings of such a divergence. One can look around a crowded bus filled with people each glued to their smart phone, tables of families at restaurants each separated by their individuated devices or an office filled with screens each telecommuting the pilot to a drone in the field thousands of miles away to see the beginnings of such a speciation. Or we could return to the beginnings of international thought, the first moments of European geopolitics and remember its multispecies beginnings when just 50 years after the arrival of Christopher Columbus Bartolomé de las Casas pleaded with the Castille thrown to recognize the soul and therefore humanity of the ‘Indios’. Instead, of course, the extermination continued which treated the people of the Americas as ‘piles of dung in the middle of the road’.64 Geopolitics was in some sense founded on the premise of many human species rather than one human species.65 The inability for so many to see their human counterpoint at a moment of encounter in the new world speaks to the precedent of a truly dark enlightenment. That is, technological and martial advance without any corresponding moral awareness. A new such speciation that included the inability to even speak to one another much less recognize some common heritage or shared community of value would make the efforts of Las Casas and those who continue to fight against the finishing of the settler-colonial project entirely potentially invisible.

Conclusion: geotechnics and a planetary state of war

when utilized to perform work highly organized collective enterprises, I shall call it the ‘labor machine’: when applied to acts of collective coercion and destruction, it deserves the title, used even today, the ‘military machine’. But when all of the components, political and economic, military, bureaucratic and royal, must be included, I shall usually refer to the ‘megamachine’.

Lewis Mumford66

Mumford’s megamachine is instructive. What he is describing is an ancient past where the political, economic, military, bureaucratic, royal all converged to form the empires of the Aztecs and Egyptians. What I have in mind is this same convergence in the future but with a twist. The ‘royal’ may come to relate to the economic and political and the military such that what we understand as politics becomes indiscernible. The megamachine of the future presented here could better be called geotechnics. The global mobilization of people, the conditions of competition and coercion, who and what was doing the competing and their relations would be fundamentally altered. The relations would no longer be linguistic or even sensory in the way that humans hold experience in common even if their subjectivizations of that experience, that is the phenomenology of body of experience, may be singular.

In a world of possible full automation, cunning machines, and posthuman speciation the equality of Hobbes’ state of nature as well as the state of war is no longer operable. If these metaphors ever did more than underwrite one particular logic of international politics they would in the future be meaningless as the people of the leviathan, the metric by which order or disorder is experienced may no longer exist in the mortal meat suit so much of political theory rests. In some sense the enmity of war in the Hobbesian sense rested on the equal finitude of every mortal human as well as the general desire to live something we could agree was a good life free from the ever presence of murder. As Hobbes was recontextualized to imagine an international system of states similarly a sense of mortal equality was present. The ability to be killed underwrote the decision to kill.

And what of the English school’s society of states? If such sociality persisted amongst neo-authoritarian states without nations what dark vision of order would that be? Basic assumption about the international system even those based on other less dour models than a realist anarchic system similarly presumes some equality of communication, the good, or the desire to live in a particular way. The material limits of homo sapiens, the necessity of water, air, food, family, and sociality underwrites everything from deterrence to diplomacy. A geotechnical system populated with intelligent things and governed by nation-less states and further populated by incommensurate branches of humanity fundamentally alters the limits and therefore the possibilities of global life and order. By what rules those relations would be conceptually governed, that is, how we could describe such a planetary system would have to reach for ways of thinking well beyond even the most radical or critical theory of international relations. In some ways efforts to consider what geopolitics looked like at the peak of the Atlantic slave trade or during the first 100 years of the conquest of the Americas more closely resemble what could become of a posthuman planet than the highly rationalized cosmopolitan institutions of the United Nations.67

Just as IR is finally accepting that global politics is inhabited by more than just nation-states that is, non-state actors, we now must also come to grips with the fact that global politics is no longer populated solely by humans and could in the future not even be dominated by humans. What new forms of intelligence mean for the transformation of peace and security is murky at best. What is clear is that a theory of automation as mere means is no longer sufficient to understanding the vast infrastructure of machines and sensory data collecting systems and the new collaborations those systems will create for former humans with which we are already beginning to share our planet. The horizon of such a technical transformation has to be thought alongside the normative upheaval and radicalization of global enmity taking place simultaneously with the transformation of the very mechanics of political and military action.

To consider a future where the actors, relations, and order of the planet could be fundamentally reconfigured by the gradual accretion of robots, algorithms, bodily and political modification poses to us the possibility of systemic change well beyond whether the world will be unipolar or multipolar. No one of these trajectories will be total or play out as described here but all of these trajectories present us with the real possibility of altering the basic rules of human planetary existence from a geopolitical condition to one that is increasingly geotechnical. Hundred years from now, what new grammar of planetary relations could be prepared to describe such a world?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.