2NC – Allied Mistrust
Either allies won’t integrate OCOs due to political, cultural, and legal constraints OR they’ll feel pressured to which causes premature, faulty system development.
Black & Lynch, 20 – Research Leader Defence, Security and Infrastructure RAND Europe J=(James Black & Alice Lynch; "Cyber Threats to NATO from a Multi-Domain Perspective"; RAND; https://ccdcoe.org/uploads/2020/12/7-Cyber_Threats_NATO_Multidomain_Perspective_ebook.pdf; 07-2020, Accessed 6-28-2022)//ILake-NoC
B. Policy Tensions
Policy differences exacerbate conceptual ones. Allies differ in their policy and legal constraints, strategic cultures, threat perception, resources, planning and budgetary cycles and forces (Sondhaus, 2006). While solidarity ultimately remains NATO’s strongest asset, these differences create seams that adversaries can exploit. This is especially so with cyberspace, where there is more sensitivity and less commonality to emerging national approaches than in more established domains, and to MDO, which is inherently predicated on integration and interoperability (Sharpy, 2020).
Information sharing is especially problematic for the cyber dimension of MDO, with Allies reticent to share details of their capabilities across NATO given security concerns and political sensitivities. The issue of permissions is also a ‘significant challenge in the development of cyber capabilities’, especially where reconnaissance on Allied soil and networks is required to detect hostile cyber activity (Watling & Roper, 2019). Nations also have differing policy, legal and ethical stances on key technologies on which MDO relies. This includes the use of offensive cyber capabilities or basing of hypersonic missiles or longrange penetrating fires in Europe, which some fear could be destabilising and escalatory (Quintin & Vanholme, 2020). NATO similarly lacks a common approach to governance and use of AI, autonomy and automation, all envisaged as essential enablers for JADC2 (Williams, 2020). This affects the levels of autonomy (with the human in, on or out of the loop) used for sensor data fusion and decision-making, or to deliver effects using uncrewed platforms, automated cyber systems and human-machine teaming (Scharre, 2018). 138 In considering cooperation and burden-sharing, Allies face several dilemmas depending on their ambitions and resources for both cyberspace and MDO. The US must overcome domestic inter-service rivalries and decide how to integrate partners, including whether it can accept a multinational vision of MDO that is not imposed on smaller allies—or excludes them entirely, at NATO’s expense—but rather is genuinely collaborative (Watling & Roper, 2019). Larger European nations face the dilemma of whether to buy into a US-led architecture and system-of-systems with implications for freedom of action, data-sharing and procurement choices, or shoulder the costs of sovereign or multinational alternatives.11 They also face choices over how best to contribute to multinational MDO: whether to aspire to full-spectrum capabilities to allow sovereign action and offer redundancy to Allies’ capabilities or to specialise in certain domains (e.g. cyber) to offer niche capability and buy leverage with the US and NATO by making themselves indispensable. Smaller nations must decide how to influence larger Allies and NATO, and what to do if they lack cyber capabilities (or others deemed central to MDO, e.g. long-range fires) or their forces are too small to operate or gain MDO experience at echelons above brigade (Watling & Roper, 2019).
The economic fallout of COVID-19 also raises renewed questions about affordability and the extent to which Allies are willing and able to invest in new cyber capabilities—though some may see these as cost-efficient alternatives to land, air or maritime forces—and how they time investments in ambitious transformation programmes such as MDO (Clark, 2020). Timing presents both threats and opportunities from a cyber perspective. Rapid, hasty transformation risks undermining NATO cohesion and interoperability or creating vulnerabilities in JADC2 systems with immature cyber defences (Donaldson & Sciarini, 2019b). Conversely, overly cautious change risks ceding ground to adversaries such as Russia and China which are investing heavily in asymmetric means, including offensive cyber capabilities, to gain an information advantage over NATO (Kilcullen, 2020).
No intra-NATO info-sharing – allies are reluctant to disclose info; they value autonomy and fear weaker countries cannot protect their info.
University of Exeter 20 – public research university in Exeter, Devon, South West England, United Kingdom. Its predecessor institutions, St Luke's College “Should NATO Adopt a Joint Offensive Cyber Capability?” 09-2020, Accessed 06-28-2022, . //ILake-NoC
Nevertheless, the largest barrier to a joint cyber capability is national intelligence agencies’ tendency to keep their activities in cyberspace highly classified.182 As Chapter 2 discussed, effective cyberattacks are utterly dependent on excellent intelligence.183 Members have significantly stepped up intelligence-sharing over the last two decades. They established the NATO Intelligence Fusion Centre in 2006, the Joint Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance initiative in 2012 and the Joint Intelligence and Security Division (JISD) in 2017. The JISD’s first Assistant Secretary General, Arndt Freytag von Loringhoven, says it has fostered a new culture of intelligence cooperation, increased efficiency and has helped avoid the duplication 37 of effort.184 Notably, he claims this new fusion of intelligence has ‘positioned the JISD to contend effectively with the… cyber… threats increasingly confronting NATO’.185
However, von Loringhoven’s optimism glosses over the great difficulty of intra-Alliance intelligence sharing. Divulging secret information is a trade-off between trusting a partner enough to share information that could endanger one’s own source against the benefits of doing so.186 Therefore, national agencies are reluctant to share it with international organisations, instead preferring bilateral cooperation on a case-by-case basis.187 It is shared between states with closely aligned interests, mutual trust and good diplomatic relations, as seen in the Anglo-American UKUSA Agreement.188 The exclusive ‘Five Eyes’ Alliance this evolved into is a rare example of multilateral intelligence sharing, involving NATO members America, Canada and the UK. These agreements tend to be more concerned with the security of the intelligence shared rather than its content, due to concerns over how other states will circulate the information. 189 Accordingly, wider intelligence cooperation within NATO would be much harder to achieve, primarily because many states do not share strong levels of trust, common interests and diplomatic relations with each other. For instance, France remains unsympathetic to intelligence integration in any multilateral environment, preferring strategic autonomy.190 This is compounded by an uneasy relationship with the Alliance, with President Emmanuel Macron calling it ‘brain dead’ in 2019.191 Furthermore, some allies fear that if countries with lower resilience are infiltrated, they could possibly compromise sensitive information shared between members.192 Consequently, apprehension about Italy’s weak cyber systems hinders allies’ propensity to share with Rome, since the potential for leaks undermines their trust.193
These concerns have resulted in a division between those member states that possess more advanced intelligence assets and those that do not. The former have been resisting serious intelligence integration, while the latter – including Belgium and The Netherlands – have even pressed for a CIA-style European agency.194 So far, NATO’s more powerful members have successfully repelled such initiatives. Following the 2015 Paris terror attacks, Belgian Prime Minister Charles Michel proclaimed the need for a ‘European CIA’.195 Nonetheless, German Interior Minister Thomas de Maizière shot this proposal down, claiming that ‘I cannot imagine we will be willing to give up our national sovereignty’.196
Unsurprisingly, NATO’s own collaborative efforts to date have also been heavily limited by national agencies’ desire for secrecy and autonomy. Pushback against greater transparency is especially strong on the part of the US, which owns a large share of NATO’s intelligence capabilities.197 not have access to all US intelligence, but NATO releasable information only.198 Such secrecy is a big practical obstacle to a joint offensive cyber capability. Although it is justified, elevating America’s role in Alliance cyber policy without increasing transparency would likely limit the tactical and strategic effectiveness of a combined offensive cyber capability.199 NATO’s intelligence fusion efforts have suffered from other, less important problems too. Different languages, cultures and infrastructures have proved to be structural constraints, while battlefield commanders have criticised the intelligence provided for lacking the strategic dimension.200 For instance, Lieutenant-General Mark Hertling judged NATO’s information on Islamic State too narrow and target-oriented, thus missing the bigger picture.201
Overall, the establishment of a joint capability would face some serious practical problems, both when confronting NATO’s internal politics and national intelligence agencies’ clandestine modus operandi. There would be significant legal hurdles to overcome too, which Chapter 4 discusses in more detail.
Black & Lynch, 20 – Research Leader Defence, Security and Infrastructure RAND Europe J=(James Black & Alice Lynch; "Cyber Threats to NATO from a Multi-Domain Perspective"; RAND; https://ccdcoe.org/uploads/2020/12/7-Cyber_Threats_NATO_Multidomain_Perspective_ebook.pdf; 07-2020, Accessed 6-28-2022)//ILake-NoC
Assuming NATO can overcome conceptual and policy hurdles, significant effort will still be required to develop the necessary forces and capabilities across all domains, but perhaps especially for cyberspace.
Operationalising MDO demands a ‘calibrated force posture’ with multi-domain formations strategically positioned, held at readiness and able to deploy over large distances, trained and equipped to operate across multiple contested domains (Grispen-Gelens, 2020). The vision is for different sensors and shooters to share and fuse data, build a common operating picture, inform rapid decision-making and deliver effects at a time and place of the commander’s choosing and to do so agnostic of domains, nation, service or platform (Niewood, Grant & Lewis, 2019). Forces must operate at pace and against an adversary contesting all domains. This tempo necessitates moving beyond NATO’s past focus on synchronisation of pre-planned effects in individual domains towards more agile targeting and more resilience against hostile attempts at ‘disorganisation’ or ‘systems attack’ (Thomas, 2019; Engstrom, 2018).
Linking all this together demands novel approaches to C4ISR, as reflected in investments in JADC2 (Harrigian, 2020). This US initiative leverages advances in information and communication technologies such as mesh networks, cloud and edge computing, open architectures, data analytics, AI and machine learning, autonomy and automation, software-defined systems, robotics, satellite communications and sophisticated cyber and EMS capabilities (Hitchens, 2019). Future JADC2 networks must be secure, robust, resilient, agile and more decentralised, with enough bandwidth to share data in a timely and secure manner despite cyber attacks, jamming, spoofing or physical destruction of communication nodes (Goldfein, 2017). Trust is also essential, handling data from different sources and at multiple security levels without making controls so arduous that users and devices cannot access the network (Donaldson & Sciarini, 2019a).
Reliance on connectivity makes cyberspace, space and the EMS the ‘centre of gravity’ for MDO (Hess et al., 2019). JADC2 introduces obvious challenges from a cyber threat perspective, both in terms of the attack surface for different threat vectors and the cascading effects from hostile cyber activity—though, of course, existing centralised C2 hubs also have their own vulnerabilities to cyber or physical attack (Hess et al., 2019). Improved cyber capabilities are not only needed to secure and enable operations in other domains (Reilly, 2020). Investments by Russia and China to contest cyberspace and the EMS may also limit the ability of NATO commanders to employ offensive cyber capabilities at a time and place that will ‘converge’ with effects through other domains. Securing networks against disruption is critical at the operational and strategic levels given requirements for reach-back to headquarters, especially constraining organisations responsible for delivering offensive cyber effects, since these are likely to be physically located in the homeland (Watling & Roper, 2019; Nettis, 2020).
D. Challenges for Command and Control
Any shift towards MDO also raises difficult questions about C2. NATO is arguably already challenged by seams when executing joint warfare, let alone a more ambitious vision of future JADC2 (Perkins & Olivieri, 2018; Zadalis, 2018). In broad terms, this could adopt a more hierarchical or de-centralised model, each with associated benefits, costs and risks (DCDC, 2015). The 140 NATO C2COE has launched an MDO C2 demonstrator to explore these issues, including how new technology might enable accelerated decision-making, reduced reliance on siloed physical command centres and a re-imagining of mission command for future MDO (NATO C2COE, 2020a).
Problematically, authorities associated with using cyber capabilities are typically held at the strategic and national level; how tactical or operational commanders might call upon cyber means as part of future MDO remains unclear (Nettis, 2020). Responsibilities for cyberspace also often fall at least partly to civilian agencies, adding the complexity of cross-government cooperation. The private sector’s role developing and applying technologies in the cyber domain (and, increasingly, space) also necessitates that NATO work more closely with industry, academia and others than for land, maritime or air operations (Ablon et al., 2019). This presents operational, policy and legal difficulties for C2, and cybersecurity challenges associated with reliance on industry-owned networks, though Allies continue to evolve novel mechanisms for partnering with industry to address cyber threats (Carr, 2016). There is also the question of tempo: how to synchronise operations in cyberspace with the delivery of effects in other domains (Reilly, 2020). Though cyber attacks might initiate in a moment, the underlying tools and exploits may take years to develop and the lead times and scale of their eventual effect may be difficult to predict or measure given the difficulties with battle damage assessment in cyberspace or the EMS (Patrikarakos, 2017; US Joint Staff, 2019). Similarly, commanders may lack awareness or understanding of available cyber instruments and their limitations and effects compared to more familiar weapons in the physical domains, limiting inclusion in joint planning and decision-making (Carbonell, 2017).
SDFSDF
University of Exeter 20 – public research university in Exeter, Devon, South West England, United Kingdom. Its predecessor institutions, St Luke's College “Should NATO Adopt a Joint Offensive Cyber Capability?” 09-2020, Accessed 06-28-2022, . //AN
Nonetheless, significant challenges remain with regard to jus in bello and cyberweapons. First, distinguishing between military and civilian targets is sometimes hard, because so many military functions and systems rely on civilian technology.225 Although Chapter 2 gave the example of air defence networks, which have little crossover with civilian networks, many other targets are more complicated. Large amounts of military communications are still sent across civilian networks, while civilian websites can be used to coordinate military operations.226 For instance, Kurdish militias in Syria used Google Earth to coordinate American airstrikes on Islamic State positions.227 Although civilian technologies used for military purposes unquestionably qualify as military objectives in times of war, they may still not qualify as legitimate targets if there is a risk of excessive collateral damage.228 Thus, cyberwarfare exacerbates the long-standing debate over the definitions of military and civilian targets.229
Second, it can be very difficult to launch a proportional cyber response, for several reasons. If Russia launched a cyberattack on a member state’s banks, as it did against Estonia, IHL would prevent NATO from launching commensurate attacks on Russian banks, because they are clearly civilian targets.230 Attacking a different target to achieve similar effects would be very hard to perform. Additionally, before launching a retaliatory cyberattack, it is difficult to anticipate whether its likely collateral damage will be excessive in relation to the anticipated military advantage gained.231 As Stuxnet demonstrated, even exceptionally well-executed cyberattacks can spread in unpredictable ways.232 If a retaliatory strike did unintentionally contravene the principles of proportionality or distinction, it would be extremely difficult to hold NATO to account. If NATO breaches IHL, its constituent members are held accountable in international courts and tribunals.233 However, it is very hard for victims to determine exactly which state is responsible because they lack mission- specific knowledge, while NATO’s documents are mostly classified.234 The highly secretive nature of cyber operations would likely aggravate this.
Finally, it would likely be very challenging to pool members’ sovereign capabilities in the first place, because they currently abide by different legal codes in cyberspace. This is even posing a problem at the CyOC. According to Eneken Tikk of the Cyber Policy Institute in Finland, the legal ‘elephant in the room’ at Mons is bringing national realities and strategic ambitions together.235 The starkest example of this problem is different member’s legal conceptions of sovereignty in cyberspace. Although France perceives any penetration of its networks as a violation of sovereignty, the UK has instigated a lively legal debate by stating that it does not recognise sovereignty in cyberspace at all.236 Moreover, the UK actually accepts that it cannot entirely conform to the laws of armed conflict when using offensive cyber in a deterrence capacity.237 It seems it would be very hard for NATO to follow international law if its own members admit they cannot. Meanwhile, with regard to jus in bello, the US labels war-sustaining objects, such as munitions factories, as military objectives susceptible to lawful attack.238 However, most other states do not adopt the US approach, most likely because attacking these targets risks infringing on the principles of proportionality and distinction.239 Overall, NATO would face three very tough legal challenges if it were to form a joint offensive cyber capability. It would have to navigate the uncertainties of jus ad bellum, before selecting targets judiciously in accordance with jus in bello. Plus, to even establish the capability, it would have to iron out some of its members’ key legal disagreements. This would not be easy and it would be unrealistic to hope to establish a joint capability in the short-term. However, it could be possible long-term, as Chapter 5 elaborates.