NATO key to prevent Hybrid War, but must shift methods of response
Underwood et. al. 22 (Major Andrew Underwood, USA, is Executive Assistant to the Deputy Director for Strategy, Plans, and Policy (J5), Europe, NATO, Russia. Colonel Andrew Emery, USAF, is the Space and Missile Defense Planner in the U.S. Military Delegation to the NATO Military Committee (JCS) at NATO Headquarters, Brussels, Belgium. Lieutenant Colonel Paul Haynsworth, USA, is currently serving in the Commander’s Action Group in the NATO Special Operations Headquarters at Supreme Headquarters Allied Powers Europe, Mons, Belgium. Commander Jennifer Barnes, USN, most recently served in the Commander’s Action Group at U.S. Africa Command Headquarters in Stuttgart, Germany), 4/14/22, accessed 6/24/22, “All Quiet in the Eastern Front: NATO Civil-Military Deterrence of Russian Hybrid Warfare”, https://ndupress.ndu.edu/Media/News/News-Article-View/Article/2999367/all-quiet-on-the-eastern-front-nato-civil-military-deterrence-of-russian-hybrid/ (JB)
As Russia has evolved to increasingly rely on hybrid warfare as a major component of its strategy, NATO must adapt accordingly. NATO’s model must shift from a reliance on traditional military deterrence and expand to incorporate political, economic, and social spheres to counter aggression below the level of armed conflict. Since NATO’s structure does not readily support innovation or active (versus passive) deterrence measures, new ideas and emphases are needed to address these challenges.
Pursuing activities to deter hybrid warfare certainly poses risks and challenges to NATO and its member states and partners. Activities in these spheres might risk further blurring lines between military and nonmilitary responsibilities. Individual member laws and EU regulations might complicate these efforts. Civil institutions could be at risk of being identified as military targets in the event of a linear war.
Consequently, Allies and partners must update their methods to better deter Russian aggression by reducing Russia’s strategic options and increasing their own ability to impose costs. Imposition of costs via Allies’ domains of diplomatic, information, military, and economic levers are central to changing Russia’s cost-benefit assessment regarding hybrid warfare and enabling deterrence. Doing this could be achieved through such concepts as comprehensive defense, improved IO, and expanded allied member and partner collaboration. While the overall goal of maintaining Alliance unity and solidarity remains the same, the means and ways through which Allies and partners achieve that goal should change. This includes embracing the diversity of members’ strengths and capabilities and exploring increased partnerships with non-NATO members to leverage and learn from their experience with Russian hybrid warfare aggression.