Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Affirmative
Opening Word document…

NATO does legal coordination through secret MOUs

Andrés B. Muñoz Mosquera 16, Legal Advisor, Director, at NATO Supreme Headquarters Allied Power, Europe - Allied Command Operations, October 2016, “Memorandum Of Understanding (MOU): A Philosophical and Empirical Approach (Part II),” NATO Legal Gazette, Issue #37, p. 34-38

The NATO Legal Deskbook briefly characterises MOUs as follows: “The form of MOU is frequently used to record informal arrangements between States on matters which are inappropriate for inclusion in treaties or where the form is more convenient than a treaty (e.g. for confidentiality). They may be drawn up as a single document using non-treaty terms, signed on behalf of two or more governments, or consist of an exchange of notes or letters recording an understanding reached between two governments, or a government and an international organization. MOUs usually do not require ratification. However depending on the content and the agreement between the Parties on the nature of the document, MOUs can be subject of a certain level of domestic ratification…NATO, in general, concludes MOUs in numerous occasions. MOUs are a very flexible and adaptable instrument to record the will of entities with legal personality to achieve practical results that do not amount to treaty obligations.”

How are MOUs practiced? There are several ‘schools’ of practice that nations and international organisations have developed, with different references to this practice in the British-law influential area5, continental European states and the United States.6 Aust highlights that in all of these areas, MOUs are considered ‘agreements without legally-binding force’ and refers to the European Commission document PESC/SEC 899 of 9 August 1996 to support his argument. Aust also admits that in certain circumstances nonbinding becomes binding.7 However, practice shows that states have different approaches depending on their political approach to the topic or topics addressed in specific MOUs.8

At this point, it is relevant to note the process for creating MOUs at NATO, a ‘classic’ international organisation practicing intergovernmentalism. At NATO, during the decision making process, members may reaffirm their sovereignty9, several times, by supporting or opposing the existence of an MOU in their collective realm. One wonders if in the process of creating MOU organisations or simple MOU initiatives there is any other international organisation in the world that gives its members so many opportunities to express their ‘super-will’10 with respect to scope and purpose, as well as to the provisions of MOUs, which are intended to implement the obligations under the foundational treaty. These treaty obligations are updated by an established practice that operates through the decisions taken, in general per the practice of consensus, by its highest decision making bodies. It is necessary to note that this consensual commitment does not only have a collective nature, as consensus reflects ineludibly the individual commitment of each of the NATO members on any specific decision taken by the Council for creating a concept supported by an MOU. In the Council’s decision, states do not particularly address the non-binding status of the MOUs. In fact, the non-binding status discussion rarely happens before the MOU text negotiations start and, normally, ends at national level exclusively mandated by political approaches or national legislation. This acts as almost pro-forma language applied dependent on a states’ individual practice and perspective, irrespective of the actual points negotiated in the MOU.

Consequently, are MOUs non-binding documents by default? How valid is the written commitment of the participants? Could the ‘bindingness’ 11 created in a non-binding environment lead to legal effects? This battery of ‘tricky’ questions, partially addressed ut supra, takes us outward to square one and convinces us that the law of parsimony fed by anterior facts and posterior behaviour surrounding the life of an MOU has to be taken into account seriously when determining its legal effects.

In this regard, MOUs are chosen for cross-border relations because there has been a previous political commitment or the basic principles of framework treaties have been implemented. The form of negotiations does not vary from that of a treaty, and in general, although there is a tendency to use lax or soft wording vis-à-vis treaties, the treaty negotiation strategies are clearly displayed. MOU texts, contrary to popular belief, have little flexibility for review once agreed upon. As such, MOU drafters incorporate predictable ‘mobile’ elements through annexes to MOUs, which negotiators assume can be opened by lower level managers, though it always requires a ‘political’ mandate either directly or indirectly.12 MOU practice shows that it is not common to incorporate reservations (statements of interpretation). However, these have recently found their way into MOUs carrying heavy and long-term financial commitments within their provisions

Compared to treaties, MOUs have, in general, shorter internal coordination processes for approval, and few states pass them through parliament or their commissions. Moreover, since most MOUs have some financial clauses related to budget and taxes, many negotiators regularly announce that their parliaments or specialised commissions need to give their approval before the state in question can consider the text of the MOU agreed upon.

Another example of how MOUs trigger complicated internal coordination processes is seen in the Host Nation Support Arrangements13 negotiated with states not party to the North Atlantic Treaty and other NATO treaties. The fact of not counting on those treaties initiates a parallel process of negotiations for concluding treaties14 on status of forces and international military headquarters. These treaties commonly address an array of matters that range from entering and staying in foreign territory, taxes and customs, wearing uniforms, holding weapons, policing compounds, claim waivers, freedom of movement, concurrent jurisdiction, etc. In addition, another significant factor is that due to confidentiality, MOUs are published only at the level of for official use only, as most of them are classified.

We must also say that MOUs often serve multiple purposes and are drafted to create a cooperation framework. This may require establishing understandings via joint procedures, or creating a sophisticated network of structures and procedures that would require detaching states’ resources abroad, which in turn increases their level of commitment and, inextricably, their expectations vis-à-vis the other participants.

Finally, we cannot conclude this section without referring to MOUs as implanting rules. Cross-border relations have, since ancient history, required minimum sets of principles that, in accordance with Dworkin, have the nature of standards that carry more weight in form of precise rules.15 This reality has been documented, for more than five thousand years, and ‘[a]ll groups of nations in regular contact had in practice adopted certain rules defining the conduct which could usually be expected among their members.’16

The principle of good faith is linked to that of estoppel, which leads us to address briefly the consequence of conflicts within MOUs.17 Since MOUs enjoy ‘all’ of the elements and principles that treaties do, we may warily open the Pandora’s Box of state responsibility, which cannot be addressed in this article. But is it true that state responsibility applies for MOUs, and is there any legal effect? MOU participants reach a consensual engagement reflected in the MOU provisions, which obliges those participants to communicate unilateral acts that can have legal effects. If those acts, fruits of a consensual engagement, are committed contrary to good faith by any participant, they are considered unfriendly acts and will, in certain cases, be void. Therefore, they will be subject, at the least, to retorsion, which is nothing other than a non-amicable act of retaliation within the bounds of proportionality, and based on good faith, common sense, and reasonableness.18 But what about justice and MOUs?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.