Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Affirmative
Opening Word document…

NATO interoperability enables effective defense of space assets. Otherwise, satellite disruptions undermine NATO operations.

Toscana and Muñoz Mosquera 21 – Borja Montes Toscano is a Legal Assistant at the Supreme Headquarters of Allied Powers Europe. Andrés Muñoz Mosquera is one of the three NATO senior legal advisors ("Legal Aspects of Space: NATO Perspectives"; NATO Legal Gazette; https://www.act.nato.int/application/files/5716/4032/2170/legal_gazette_42.pdf; 12-2021, Accessed 6-27-2022)//ILake-AZ

The space domain has recently become a new field full of new opportunities due to the advancements in technology. Nevertheless, vulnerabilities may arise as states and private companies exploit this domain to achieve strategic competitive advantage in different areas (e.g. weather monitoring, transport, environment and agriculture, science, communications, among others), and draw benefits out of them. These realities may pose challenges to the existing rule of law in the space domain leading to legal uncertainty and an apparent governance vacuum. In addition, possible technological disruptions (e.g. satellites’ interferences) may distort information gathered, which is essential for NATO’s operations and missions, including collective defence, crisis response and counter-terrorism.

Hence, these concerns have resulted in NATO’s new space policy, and in this way recognizing space as new operational domain two years ago.4 The 1980s and 1990s bore witness that concluding new binding agreements for outer space matters beyond the existing ones would be extremely difficult. However, the fluid legal regime for the outer space does not entail that customary international law is inapplicable.5 The crystallization of an international customary norm is a lengthy process, as is the development of treaties, and thus the introduction of a Rules-Based International Order (RBIO). Several factors within the space domain cannot be under-estimated by the Alliance such as space-based strike weapons, space support for the Alliance’s operations or dual-use material/devices.

These challenges emphasize the need to complete policy and doctrine to achieve better interoperability and resilience among Allies and contribute to forge a network of reliable soft law. NATO’s inclusion of space as the fifth operational domain represents a step forward in support of the principles of the Charter of the United Nations and on NATO’s pathos of collective self-defence and consultation, as enshrined in articles 4 (consultation) and 5 (collective defence) of the Washington Treaty. Hence, such inclusion is an additional feature of the adaptability of these provisions to armed attacks (including nonconventional tactics).6 Bearing in mind the Alliance’s institutionalized procedures and the behaviours observed over the past years in formal and informal domains, including the space domain, hybrid threats will continue proliferating at the left and the right of article 5.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.