Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Currently, NATO requires individual member nations to coordinate offensive cyber operations.

Freedberg, 18 (Sydney Freedberg, Sydney J. Freedberg Jr. is the deputy editor for Breaking Defense. graduated summa cum laude from Harvard and holds masters' degrees from Cambridge and Georgetown., 11-16-2018, accessed on 6-17-2022, Breaking Defense, "NATO To ‘Integrate’ Offensive Cyber By Members - Breaking Defense", https://breakingdefense.com/2018/11/nato-will-integrate-offensive-cyber-by-member-states/)//Babcii

Independent Assets, Coordinated Action It’s crucial to understand that NATO doesn’t have its own combat units in any domain. It pulls together assets provided by its 29 members. “It’s the nations who actually , through the NATO force structure,” Col. Lewis emphasized. “They bring their ships, their planes, their tanks…. Those sovereign capabilities are exactly that: sovereign.” “They’re responsible for defending those things,” including in cyberspace, Lewis continued. “It’s out job to make sure we have situational awareness of how they’re defending those things and how their success may or may not have an impact on the overall operation.” In cyberspace as on land, air, or sea, NATO member nations can act either collectively, through the alliance, or individually, as sovereign states. But acting outside alliance channels doesn’t bar them from coordinating with each other: Contrast the war in , which was long run as a , and the war in , waged by a “coalition of the willing” outside the alliance but involving multiple nations that happened to be NATO members. A NATO member can even divorce itself from the alliance’s military structure but still participate in NATO operations, as did from . So while NATO, by charter, renounces offensive operations, its members can still conduct them — on their own legal authority as sovereign states, but, if they wish, in coordination with each other and in consultation with NATO. With that in mind, here’s a more formal and precise description, which I drafted but which NATO officials read, revised and agreed is accurate: “In all domains — land, air, maritime, and (as of 2016) cyber — NATO relies on forces contributed by its member nations to conduct military operations. “In all domains, NATO operations are governed by the consensus of all 29 member states, executed by SACEUR and subordinate commanders in accordance with the constraints of the approved operation. “In all domains, if a NATO member state decides to conduct an operation using its own forces and its own legal authorities, it may choose to inform NATO command structures and coordinate with NATO plans and operations. “How this applies in the cyber domain specifically: NATO policy, as set by the consensus of the 29 members, is that the alliance itself, in keeping with its defensive mindset, shall not conduct offensive cyber operations. However, this does not restrict unilateral or multilateral offensive operations by NATO member states. NATO policy — again, by member consensus — does provide for the integration of sovereign cyberspace effects provided by Allies with the ability and willingness to provide them. That integration into Allied operations and missions will be orchestrated by the NATO CYOC (Cyber Operations Centre).” As I interpret this, a NATO commander, acting in his or her alliance capacity, couldn’t order anyone to conduct an offensive cyber operation. But the same commander could suggest an offensive cyber operation, and one or more of the member states could then voluntarily conduct it. Or a commander with a dual NATO and national role could simply take off his NATO hat and use the authority granted him by his own nation to order his own nation’s forces to conduct a cyber attack. The obvious candidate here is , who is both NATO’s (SACEUR) and , US European Command (EUCOM). In either case, the national forces conducting the attack can coordinate with other alliance members, through NATO organizations, to “integrate” the attack with the alliance’s collective defense operations. For cyberspace specifically, this coordination and integration role is played by the new Cyber Operations Center. It’s as a logical extension of CYOC’s “situational awareness” mission to share information among the member states about what each of them is observing and doing in cyberspace. “NATO doesn’t do offense, but it will integrate sovereign effects from the nations that are capable and willing to provide them,” Lewis said. “Some nations have stated their willingness to . The role of the CYOC is simply to integrate it into the operations in the same way we integrate all the other arrows in the quiver.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.