Inability of NATO to cohere integration of OCO’s into the alliance risks fracturing the alliance
Iftimie, 20 (Ion Iftimie, Eisenhower PhD Candidate Fellow, NATO Defense College, and Senior Advisor, European Union Research Center, George Washington University School of Business, 5-28-2020, accessed on 6-17-2022, NDC, "NATO’s needed offensive cyber capabilities", https://www.ndc.nato.int/news/news.php?icode=1441)//Babcii
NATO Cyber Rapid Reaction teams are already equipped to conduct defensive cyber operations in support of member states if called upon. A mandate of cyber defence and security implies, however, that NATO also starts to engage in active military measures to deny, degrade, disrupt, deceive, or destroy an adversary’s offensive cyber capabilities. This requires the development of not only offensive cyber A2/AD capabilities by Allies, but also the restructuring of the NATO command structures, policies, processes (procurement, intelligence, operations, etc.) and engagements needed to integrate them by the Alliance. NATO coordination with both national and regional entities charged with cyber security aspects will, in particular, need to be enhanced. Many agreements already exist in the realm of defensive cyber at national and regional levels (as seen with the 2016 NATO-EU Technical Arrangement on Cyber Defence), but political consensus among Allies is missing on whether they should be expanded to incorporate the collective use of offensive cyber A2/AD capabilities. Conclusion The lack of integrated offensive cyber A2/AD capabilities undermines both the unity of the Alliance and its mandate of defence and deterrence. On the former, the lack of coordination between Allies during unilateral cyber operations could lead to friction when resulting effects infringe on Allied cyber-physical infrastructures. It could also lead to cyber fratricide, when failure to properly attribute Allied digital personas occurs during these military operations. On the latter, while most Allies are developing offensive cyber capabilities, some remain unable to face the growing number of cyber threats unilaterally. Successful defence and deterrence in the cyber domain calls, thus, for ready collective offensive cyber A2/AD capabilities that, when integrated with NATO operations, would complement national and/ or regional responses to malicious cyber activities. If and when this integration occurs, NATO Flexible Deterrence Options would also need to be agreed upon in order to signal cyber adversaries that Allies will respond with one voice if attacked in the cyber domain. Ultimately, political consensus within the Alliance would still need to be built on the type of needed collective offensive cyber capabilities (such as for A2/ AD purposes) and on how to integrate them into NATO’s existing operations and missions.