Alliance wide cyber information sharing is critical for operational strength
Canbolat and Sezgin, 16 (Mustafa Canbolat and Emrah Sezgin, 1st Lieutenant, Turkish ArmyB.S., Turkish Military Academy, 2008 , 1st Lieutenant, Turkish Air ForceB.S., Turkish Air Force Academy, 2009, December 2016, accessed on 6-16-2022, DTIC, "Is NATO Ready for a Cyberwar", https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/citations/AD1030734)//Babcii
b. Recommendations As Matthijs Veenendaal, Kadri Kaska, and Pascal Brangetto (2016) note, cyber capabilities are still regarded as strategic assets by most states. Because of the secrecy of these capabilities, states are reluctant to delegate the authority to use them, particularly in offensive operations. For instance, in the United States, “only the President can approve a cyber-attack likely to result in ‘significant consequences.’ However, this does not mean that these capabilities are irrelevant to NATO and NATO-led operations” (Veenendaal et al., 2016). NATO must plan for the “contingency of nations wanting to deploy them during a NATO-led military operation” (Veenendaal et al., 2016). However, without information sharing and knowing the level of possible contribution of an allied member, it will be very difficult to plan for possible cyber scenarios and react swiftly to cyber-attacks against NATO and its members. Handling “the need for secrecy or political sensitivity concerning specific military operations is not new for the Alliance” (Veenendaal et al., 2016). To enhance a full-fledged cyber doctrine, it would be beneficial to check the NATO Allied Joint Doctrine for Special Operations. It states in its introduction that special operations may be described as military activities conducted by specially designated, organized, trained, and equipped forces using operational tactics, techniques, and modes of employment not standard to conventional forces. Politico-military considerations may require low prominence, covert or discreet techniques, and the acceptance of a degree of physical and political risk not associated with conventional operations. (Veenendaal et al., 2016) The approach for special operations is applicable for NATO to develop information sharing among members for cyber operations. NATO has the capacity to develop a sound doctrine, which deals with unconventional small sized units depending on secret information and conducting clandestine operations. Countries hesitate to share information because of their vulnerabilities in the cyber domain; however, if NATO becomes a more powerful cyber actor, willingness to share information among members will increase, and the bonds of NATO members will strengthen.