Info sharing with NATO is critical to effectively attribute responsibility for cyberattacks
Maigre 22 – senior cybersecurity expert at e-Governance Academy in Estonia
Merle Maigre, "NATO’s Role in Global Cyber Security," German Marshall Fund of the United States, 4-6-2022, https://www.gmfus.org/news/natos-role-global-cyber-security
When should states publicly attribute cyberattacks? Effective public attribution requires a clear understanding of the attributed cyber operation and the cyber-threat actor, but also the broader geopolitical environment, allied positions and activities, and the legal context. The public attribution framework put forward by Max Smeets and Florian Egloff in March 202127 distinguishes four factors that act as enablers or constraints in public attribution. These factors are intelligence, incident severity, geopolitical context, and post-attribution actions. The combination of these four components enables consistent decision-making about whether to publicly disseminate information about an adversary’s actions, privately tell the adversary, or restrict knowledge of the intrusion to the government and potentially other partners.
Collecting and processing intelligence—information about foreign countries and their agents—provides a technical basis for attribution. How could allies improve intelligence sharing to conduct more rapid attribution and enable a response to adversary cyber activity? During the Nordic-Baltic foreign ministers meeting in Tallinn in September 2020, a 90-minute tabletop exercise was organized28 to test the ministers’ ability to respond to and attribute an escalating cyberattack. They answered multiple-choice questions on communication of and possible diplomatic countermeasures to the attack. The ministers learned through first-hand experience that a timely exchange of technical intelligence can be key in attributing any cyberattack. “The shared view [of the countries involved]—especially when it comes to complicated issues—is crucial,” said Urmas Reinsalu, Foreign Minister of Estonia.29
Attribution is only as good as the information that allies are willing to share. NATO’s value can be in becoming the preferred platform for sharing cyber information. General Paul Nakasone, who heads US Cyber Command, told the House Armed Services subcommittee on intelligence that “in 35 years” he has never seen a better sharing of accurate, timely, and actionable intelligence than what has transpired with Ukraine.30 Sharing information and intelligence with allies “builds coalitions” and can “shine a light on disinformation” campaigns, like the one Russia used to lay the groundwork for their invasion of Ukraine.