Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Meltdowns make Earth unlivable.

Slocum 15 — Christopher Slocum, Researcher at Arizona Oil & Gas, J.D. from University of Missouri-Kansas City School of Law, 2015 (“A Theory for Human Extinction: Mass Coronal Ejection and Hemispherical Nuclear Meltdown,” The Hidden Costs of Alternative Energy Series The Hidden Costs of Alternative Energy Series, July 21st, Available Online at http://azoilgas.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Theory-for-Human-Extinction-Slocum-20151003.pdf)

With our intelligence we have littered the planet with massive spent nuclear fuel pools, emitting lethal radiation in over-crowded conditions, with circulation requirements of electricity, water-supply, and neutron absorbent chemicals. The failure of any of these conditions for any calculable or incalculable reason, will release all of a pool’s cesium into the atmosphere, causing 188 square miles to be contaminated, 28,000 cancer deaths and $59 billion in damage. As of 2003, 49,000 tons of SNF was stored at 131 sites with an additional 2,000-2,400 metric tons produced annually. The NRC has issued permits, and the nuclear industry has amassed unfathomable waste on the premise that a deep geological storage facility would be available to remediate the waste. The current chances for a deep geological storage facility look grim. The NAS has required geologic stability for 1,000,000 years. It is impossible to calculate any certainty 1,000,000 years into the future. Humanity could not even predict the mechanical failures at Three Mile Island or Chernobyl, nor could it predict the size of the tsunami that triggered three criticality events at Fukushima Daiichi. These irremediable crises span just over 70 years of human history.

How can the continued production and maintenance of SNF in pools be anything but a precedent to an unprecedented human cataclysm? The Department of Energy’s outreach website explains nuclear fission for power production, providing a timeline of the industry. The timeline ends, as does most of the world’s reactor construction projects in the 1990s, with the removal of the FCMs from Three Mile Island. One would think the timeline would press into the current decade, however the timeline terminates with the question, “How can we minimize the risk? What do we do with the waste?” (The History of Nuclear Energy 12). Nearly fifteen years into the future, these questions are no closer to an answer. The reactors at Fukushima Daiichi are still emitting radioisotopes into the atmosphere, and their condition is unstable. TEPCO has estimated it could take forty years to recover all of the fuel material, and there are doubts as to whether the decontamination effort can withstand that much time (Schneider 72). A detailed analysis of Chernobyl has demonstrated that nuclear fall-out, whether from thermonuclear explosions, spent fuel pool fires, or reactor core criticality events are deleterious to the food-chain. Cesium and strontium are taken into the roots of plants and food crops, causing direct human and animal contamination from ingestion, causing cancer, teratogenicity, mutagenesis and death. Vegetation suffers mutagenesis, reproductive loss, and death. Radioactive fields and forest floors decimate invertebrate and rodent variability and number necessary to supply nature’s food-chain and life cycles. The flesh and bones of freshwater and oceanic biota contribute significantly to the total radiation dose in the food-chain. Fresh water lakes, rivers and streams become radioactive. Potable aquafers directly underlying SNFs and FCMs are penetrated by downward migration of radioisotopes. Humans must eat to live. Humans must have water. No human can survive 5 Sv of exposure to ionizing radiation, many cannot survive exposure to 1 Sv.

Realizing the irremediable devastation caused by one thermonuclear warhead, by one Chernobyl, by one Fukushima Daiichi, it remains to be said that the earth can handle as many simultaneous loss of coolant failures as nature can create. Humanity cannot. It is not good enough to lead by relegating probable human wide extinction phenomena to an appeal to lack of evidence. Policy cannot indefinitely ignore responsibility by requiring further study. Nor can leadership idle into cataclysm by relying on the largest known natural phenomena of the last 200 years. Permitting construction and continued operation of malefic machinery, based on 200 years of cataclysmic experience is a protocol for calamity. Of coronal mass ejections, Hapgood warns, that we need to prepare for a once-in-1000-year event, not just simulate infrastructure safeties by the measure of what we have seen in the past. The same is true for all natural phenomena. The future of humanity is too precious to operate with such insouciance. The engineering is not good enough. It never will be. Nature is too unpredictable, and nuclear power is too dangerous.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.