Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchGeorgetown2022Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Network intrusions are the largest internal link --- They destroy confidence in the alliance --- Sustained cooperation and integration is essential

Smeets, 21 (Max Smeets, Center for Security Studies, ETH Zürich (Switzerland), Aug 2021, accessed on 6-19-2022, Hcss, "NATO Allies' offensive cyber policy: A growing divide?", https://hcss.nl/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/Essay-3-NATO-allies-offensive-cyber-policy-A-growing-divide-3.pdf)//Babcii

Steady divergence Yet when it comes to the direction of allies’ cyber policy, growing differences are apparent – especially in the development and deployment offensive cyber capabilities. First, even though most states now have – or are in the process of – establishing a cyber command, operational capabilities vastly differ across states. Whereas some governments are increasingly allocating significant resources to conduct cyber operations – and are now starting to benefit from these investments – the majority of allies still run their cyber commands on a budget of a few million a year –an amount that is insufficient for effective operations in the cyber domain. Secondly, until a few years ago, NATO members’ strategic visions were largely aligned. National cyber strategies shared a common threat focus on operations that could potentially cause major societal havoc, such as taking down the power grid. Allies’ national strategies were also largely unified in their vision to address this threat, discussing the need for deterrence, resilience, and norms. However, this changed with the publication of the US Department of Defense’s strategy on Defend Forward and US Cyber Command’s vision on Persistent Engagement. The United States emphasizes the need to cause friction “wherever the adversary maneuvers,” operating “globally, continuously and seamlessly” (potentially) below the threshold of armed attack. “We must…maneuver seamlessly across the interconnected battlespace, globally, as close as possible to adversaries and their operations, and continuously shape the battlespace to create operational advantage for us while denying the same to our adversaries,” in the words of NSA director and Cyber Command head Gen. Paul Nakasone. Whereas deterrence is about changing your adversary’s cost-benefit calculus, Persistent Engagement is about taking the opportunity away from the adversary to act. Third, NATO member positions on how international law applies – particularly the obligations of states vis-a-vis sovereignty – are now more divergent than a decade ago. Whereas countries like the Netherlands and France are located on the side of the “sovereignty as a rule” camp, the United Kingdom has taken the position that a remote cyber operation by one state into another’s cyber systems or network does not violate the latter’s sovereignty. Where to go from here? The divergence in cyber policy across NATO member states is problematic. Allies disagree on both the goals of cyber policy and the ways and means to achieve them. This can cause tension between allies, especially when it comes to the necessity and legitimacy of operating on each other’s national systems and networks. Some may argue that these differences result from differences in maturity. Some states simply have not caught up with the latest developments, goes the argument. This assumes a single path to cyber maturity or that the dynamics of cyberspace pull all states in the same direction. It suggests that – even without major policy coordination – allies’ cyber policies will converge over time. But a more persuasive understanding of the current trend is that even though states can learn from each other’s institutional progress, differences do not merely stem from states “lagging behind.” These states are on a different policy path. This means it requires dedicated and sustained policy attention to, at a minimum, coordinating the different policies of states – and potentially bring them closer together.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.