US expertise and resources necessary for quick and flexible NATO cyber response
Albon et al., 22 (Lillian Albon, Anika Binnendijk, Quentin E. Hodgson, Bilyana Lilly, Sasha Romanosky, David Senty, Julia A. ThompsonLillian Ablon is an information scientist at the RAND Corporation and a professor at the Pardee RAND Graduate School., 6-1-2022, accessed on 6-16-2022, Rand, "Cyberspace as a Military Domain: Lessons for NATO", https://www.rand.org/pubs/perspectives/PE329.html)//Babcii
The integration of cyber effects into military operations to operationalize the domain fully is an ongoing process at the national level, just as it is an area of development for NATO. The United States, for example, has experimented with multiple approaches to develop planning processes and personnel to integrate with operational staffs—including liaison officers from its Cyber Command to the geographic and other functional combatant commands and creating Joint Cyber Centers across the headquarters staffs to combine intelligence, operations, planning, and communications—but these approaches are still evolving. In addition, the authorities to execute cyber operations, while often focused on offensive action, are also an ongoing discussion in defensive operations. This is where a series of high-level strategy and operational tabletop exercises can inform NATO how best to identify the key issues, experiment with alternative constructs, and evaluate the most useful approach that works for the alliance. Workforce NATO will need staff officers, civilian personnel, and other augmentees who not only are steeped in the technical aspects of cyberspace but also understand how cyberspace operations can contribute to the overall success of NATO NATO concluded an agreement with the Estonian government in 2014 to leverage its national cyber range for NATO use.52 Determining whether this range architecture is sufficient for all of NATO’s needs will first depend on conducting a needs assessment and capability gap analysis. It is reasonable to conclude that NATO’s exercise and training regimen for cyberspace will grow in the coming years, which would indicate a need for more capacity and certainly a need for greater range capability to adapt to changing technology.